Vellore Village Pet Hospital, Vaughan, Ontario, Canada.
The Mountain-Whisper-Light, Seattle, Washington, USA.
Vet Rec. 2022 Feb;190(3):e503. doi: 10.1002/vetr.503. Epub 2021 Jun 6.
Given the increase in antimicrobial drug resistance of several pathogens that affect the ear, there is a need for alternative therapy for canine otitis externa (OE). We hypothesised that the efficacy of modified Burow's solution would be non-inferior to that of standard treatment with Surolan.
The treatment success rate of a topical aluminum acetate 2% and betamethasone 0.1% (modified Burow's) otic solution was compared with that of a standard topical otic treatment of polymyxin B sulfate, prednisolone acetate and miconazole (Surolan) suspension in a prospective, open-label clinical trial. For 10 days, 142 dogs (232 ears) with OE were treated with modified Burow's solution or Surolan. The primary study endpoint was the cure rate at 10 days. Clinical efficacy was analysed as a secondary endpoint but without assessment for non-inferiority.
The 10-day OE cure rate was 65% and 59% in the Burow's and Surolan groups, respectively. The modified Burow's solution was non-inferior to Surolan at a non-inferiority margin of -11.5% and was more clinically effective than Surolan in dogs with OE caused by yeast or bacteria.
The results of this study demonstrate that modified Burow's solution is an effective treatment for OE in dogs.
鉴于影响耳部的几种病原体对抗菌药物的耐药性增加,需要为犬外耳炎(OE)提供替代疗法。我们假设改良的 Burow 溶液的疗效不亚于标准的 Surolan 治疗。
在一项前瞻性、开放标签的临床试验中,比较了 2%醋酸铝和 0.1%倍他米松(改良 Burow 溶液)滴耳液的局部治疗成功率与硫酸多粘菌素 B、醋酸泼尼松龙和咪康唑(Surolan)混悬液的标准局部治疗。142 只(232 只耳朵)患有 OE 的狗接受了改良 Burow 溶液或 Surolan 治疗,为期 10 天。主要研究终点是 10 天的治愈率。临床疗效作为次要终点进行分析,但不评估非劣效性。
改良 Burow 溶液组和 Surolan 组的 10 天 OE 治愈率分别为 65%和 59%。改良 Burow 溶液的非劣效性优于 Surolan,非劣效性边界为-11.5%,并且在由酵母或细菌引起的 OE 犬中比 Surolan 更具临床疗效。
这项研究的结果表明,改良 Burow 溶液是治疗犬 OE 的有效方法。