Kim Sage J, Peterson Caryn E, Warnecke Richard, Barrett Richard, Glassgow Anne Elizabeth
Divisions of Health Policy and Administration, School of Public Health, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
Divisions of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, School of Public Health, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
Health Equity. 2020 Dec 30;4(1):556-564. doi: 10.1089/heq.2020.0023. eCollection 2020.
Safety net health services, such as federally funded health clinics, are interventions that aim to mitigate inequality in resource distribution, thus primarily clustered in poor areas with lack of access to health care. However, not all neighborhoods with the most needs benefit from safety net health services. In this article, we explore the distribution of a federally funded health service intervention designed to serve impoverished areas, the medically underserved areas (MUAs), and the relationship between MUA designation and neighborhood sociodemographic characteristics. We explore the spatial distribution of MUAs. The 2010 U.S. census data including 868 census tracts in Chicago were used for the analysis. We then examined the likelihood of being designated as an MUA using census tract level neighborhood demographic variables. We found that the likelihood of obtaining MUA designation increases for neighborhoods with higher levels of poverty, the likelihood of being designated as an MUA begins to decline beyond the tipping point, whereas the proportion of black residents continues to increase. In census tracts that were eligible but not designated, there was a greater proportion of black residents compared with white residents (<0.01). The census tracks also had higher mean disadvantage scores (<0.01) and lower social capital (<0.01). Furthermore, MUA eligible areas that were not designated as MUAs were predominantly black neighborhoods in poverty. Studies have documented that receiving MUA designation substantially reduces disparities in access to health care, and yet, our study finding indicates that the most racially segregated poor neighborhoods are excluded from the benefits of having such federal health safety net program. Seemingly race-neutral safety net health services may still be distributed in a way that perpetuates racial inequality in health.
安全网健康服务,如联邦政府资助的健康诊所,是旨在缓解资源分配不平等的干预措施,因此主要集中在缺乏医疗服务的贫困地区。然而,并非所有最需要的社区都能从安全网健康服务中受益。在本文中,我们探讨了一项旨在服务贫困地区、医疗服务不足地区(MUA)的联邦政府资助的健康服务干预措施的分布情况,以及MUA指定与社区社会人口特征之间的关系。我们研究了MUA的空间分布。分析使用了2010年美国人口普查数据,包括芝加哥的868个人口普查区。然后,我们使用人口普查区层面的社区人口变量来研究被指定为MUA的可能性。我们发现,贫困程度较高的社区被指定为MUA的可能性增加,超过临界点后被指定为MUA的可能性开始下降,而黑人居民的比例继续上升。在符合条件但未被指定的人口普查区中,黑人居民的比例高于白人居民(<0.01)。这些人口普查区的平均劣势得分也更高(<0.01),社会资本更低(<0.01)。此外,未被指定为MUA的符合MUA条件的地区主要是贫困的黑人社区。研究表明,获得MUA指定可大幅减少医疗服务获取方面的差距,然而,我们的研究结果表明,种族隔离最严重的贫困社区被排除在这种联邦健康安全网计划的益处之外。看似种族中立的安全网健康服务的分配方式可能仍然会使健康方面的种族不平等长期存在。