Konno Hiroyuki, Kamiya Kinji, Takahashi Arata, Kumamaru Hiraku, Kakeji Yoshihiro, Marubashi Shigeru, Hakamada Kenichi, Miyata Hiroaki, Seto Yasuyuki
The Japanese Society of Gastroenterological Surgery Database Committee Tokyo Japan.
Hamamatsu University School of Medicine Hamamatsu Japan.
Ann Gastroenterol Surg. 2021 Feb 20;5(3):304-313. doi: 10.1002/ags3.12431. eCollection 2021 May.
We evaluated the association of profiles of institutional departments with operative outcomes of eight major gastroenterological procedures.
We administered a 15-item online survey to 2634 institutional departments in 2016 to investigate the association of questionnaire responses with operative mortality for the procedures. The proportions of conditions met were listed according to institutional volume and classified according to annual operative cases in 1464 departments. Group A included departments with annual performance of <40 cases of the eight procedures, B 40-79 cases, C 80-199 cases, D 200-499 cases, and E ≥ 500 cases. We evaluated the number of conditions met for 10 of 15 items that could be improved by efforts of institutional departments, to assess whether the profiles of institutional departments had impacts on operative mortality. We built a multivariable logistic regression model for operative mortality with facilities categorized based on the number of conditions met and procedure-specific predicted mortality as explanatory variables using generalized estimating equation to account for facility-level clustering. We also examined how operative outcomes differed between facilities meeting nine or more conditions and those that did not.
We recognized meeting nine out of the 10 conditions as being a good indicator for having appropriate structural and process measures for gastroenterological surgery. The facilities meeting nine or more of the conditions had better operative mortality for all eight procedures.
Our findings reveal that the profiles of institutional departments can reflect the outcomes of gastroenterological surgery in Japan.
我们评估了机构科室概况与八项主要胃肠手术的手术结局之间的关联。
2016年,我们对2634个机构科室进行了一项包含15个项目的在线调查,以研究问卷回复与这些手术的手术死亡率之间的关联。根据机构手术量列出符合条件的比例,并根据1464个科室的年度手术病例进行分类。A组包括每年进行八项手术少于40例的科室,B组为40 - 79例,C组为80 - 199例,D组为200 - 499例,E组为≥500例。我们评估了15项中10项可通过机构科室努力改善的符合条件的数量,以评估机构科室概况是否对手术死亡率有影响。我们构建了一个手术死亡率的多变量逻辑回归模型,将根据符合条件的数量分类的机构以及特定手术的预测死亡率作为解释变量,使用广义估计方程来考虑机构层面的聚类。我们还研究了符合九个或更多条件的机构与不符合条件的机构之间手术结局的差异。
我们认为满足10项条件中的9项是胃肠手术具备适当结构和流程措施的良好指标。满足九个或更多条件的机构在所有八项手术中的手术死亡率更低。
我们的研究结果表明,机构科室概况能够反映日本胃肠手术的结局。