School of Social Welfare, University of Kansas, Lawrence, USA.
J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci. 2021 Oct 30;76(9):1904-1912. doi: 10.1093/geronb/gbab102.
Media sources have consistently described older adults as a medically vulnerable population during the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, yet a lack of concern over their health and safety has resulted in dismissal and devaluation. This unprecedented situation highlights ongoing societal ageism and its manifestations in public discourse. This analysis asks how national news sources performed explicit and implicit ageism during the first month of the pandemic.
Using content and critical discourse analysis methods, we analyzed 287 articles concerning older adults and COVID-19 published between March 11 and April 10, 2020, in 4 major U.S.-based newspapers.
Findings indicate that while ageism was rarely discussed explicitly, ageist bias was evident in implicit reporting patterns (e.g., frequent use of the term "elderly," portrayals of older adults as "vulnerable"). Infection and death rates and institutionalized care were among the most commonly reported topics, providing a limited portrait of aging during the pandemic. The older "survivor" narrative offers a positive alternative by suggesting exceptional examples of resilience and grit. However, the survivor narrative may also implicitly place blame on those unable to survive or thrive in later life.
This study provides insight for policy makers, researchers, and practitioners exploring societal perceptions of older adults and how these perceptions are disseminated and maintained by the media.
媒体一直将老年人描述为在 2019 冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行期间易受医疗影响的人群,但对他们的健康和安全缺乏关注导致他们被忽视和贬低。这种前所未有的情况突显了持续存在的社会年龄歧视及其在公共话语中的表现。本分析探讨了在大流行的第一个月,美国四大报纸中的新闻媒体如何在报道中表现出明显和隐含的年龄歧视。
我们采用内容分析法和批评话语分析方法,分析了 2020 年 3 月 11 日至 4 月 10 日期间,4 家美国主流报纸上发表的 287 篇有关老年人和 COVID-19 的文章。
研究结果表明,虽然年龄歧视很少被明确讨论,但年龄歧视偏见在隐含的报道模式中显而易见(例如,频繁使用“老年人”一词,将老年人描绘为“脆弱”)。感染和死亡率以及机构化护理是最常报道的话题,这提供了大流行期间老龄化的有限画像。“幸存”叙事提供了一个积极的替代方案,暗示了在晚年生活中具有非凡的弹性和坚韧的例子。然而,幸存者叙事也可能在无形中将责任归咎于那些无法在晚年幸存或茁壮成长的人。
本研究为政策制定者、研究人员和实践者提供了关于社会对老年人的看法的见解,以及这些看法是如何通过媒体传播和维持的。