Subramanian A, Hegde G, Azzopardi C, Davies A M, Patel A, James S L, Botchu R
Department of Musculoskeletal Radiology, Royal Orthopedic Hospital, Birmingham, UK.
J Clin Orthop Trauma. 2021 May 27;19:196-199. doi: 10.1016/j.jcot.2021.05.030. eCollection 2021 Aug.
MR and CT are excellent complimentary diagnostic modalities for evaluation of hip pain which are often used together along with radiographs. However, CT involves radiation, which is a concern particularly in younger patients. T1VIBE is a 3D gradient echo MR sequence with high intrinsic contrast between the bone and soft tissues with multiplanar capabilities.
We performed a study to assess if TIVIBE can be used to complement MR for evaluation of hip pain in young adults and to see if measurements and angles can be calculated using T1VIBE inversion images with similar accuracy to CT scan.
A retrospective review of 50 patients aged less than 40 years, who had MR (including TIVIBE) and CT of pelvis was performed. Post surgical patients were excluded. Some important measurements such as Centre edge angle, Tonnis' angle, anterior acetabular sector angle, posterior acetabular sector angle and acetabular version were independently measured by two readers on T1 VIBE inversion and CT images separately and measurements were compared. One reader performed the measurements again to assess for intra-observer error.
There was a female predominance (37 F, 13M) with an average age of 27.6 years (range of 17-39). There was no significant difference in the measurements between CT and TI VIBE inversion and there was good intra and interobservor reliability.
TI VIBE inversion sequence can be used as an alternative to CT with added advantage of alleviating the radiation exposure.
磁共振成像(MR)和计算机断层扫描(CT)是评估髋关节疼痛的优秀互补诊断方式,它们常与X线片一起使用。然而,CT涉及辐射,这在年轻患者中尤其令人担忧。T1VIBE是一种三维梯度回波MR序列,在骨组织和软组织之间具有高固有对比度,并具备多平面成像能力。
我们进行了一项研究,以评估T1VIBE是否可用于补充MR以评估年轻成年人的髋关节疼痛,以及使用T1VIBE反相位图像计算测量值和角度的准确性是否与CT扫描相似。
对50例年龄小于40岁、已接受骨盆MR(包括T1VIBE)和CT检查的患者进行回顾性研究。排除术后患者。由两名阅片者分别独立测量T1VIBE反相位图像和CT图像上的一些重要测量值,如中心边缘角、托尼角、髋臼前扇区角、髋臼后扇区角和髋臼扭转,并对测量值进行比较。一名阅片者再次进行测量以评估观察者内误差。
女性占优势(37例女性,13例男性),平均年龄27.6岁(范围17 - 39岁)。CT与T1VIBE反相位图像的测量值之间无显著差异,且观察者内和观察者间的可靠性良好。
T1VIBE反相位序列可作为CT的替代方法,其额外优势在于可减轻辐射暴露。