Miller W E, Vittitoe J, O'Rourke R A, Crawford M H
University of Texas Health Science Center, San Antonio 78284-7872.
Am J Cardiol. 1988 Sep 1;62(7):372-6. doi: 10.1016/0002-9149(88)90961-7.
Combination beta-blocker and calcium antagonist therapy has been shown to be superior to monotherapy with either class of drugs in the treatment of patients with severe angina pectoris. Some combinations of these agents have resulted in an increased frequency of adverse effects. Although nadolol and diltiazem have low incidences of side effects as monotherapy, little is known about their combination. Thus, 18 patients with angina pectoris despite medical therapy were randomly assigned to 3-week periods of nadolol (160 mg/day), diltiazem (240 mg/day) or their combination. At the end of each treatment period, treadmill exercise testing and rest and peak bicycle exercise 2-dimensional echocardiography were performed. The heart rate-systolic blood pressure product was decreased most at peak treadmill exercise with the combination therapy versus monotherapy with either nadolol or diltiazem (12 vs 14 vs 22 x 10(3), respectively, p less than 0.05). Exercise duration did not differ with any of the 3 regimens, but the number of patients without angina during exercise was lowest with the combination therapy versus nadolol or diltiazem alone (5, 10 and 11, respectively, p less than 0.05); similar results were noted with the number of patients developing 1-mm ST depression on the exercise electrocardiogram (6, 10 and 13, respectively, p less than 0.05). The left ventricular ejection fraction at rest and during peak exercise was similar among the 3 treatments. The therapeutic combination of nadolol and diltiazem is well tolerated and results in less evidence of myocardial ischemia during exercise than monotherapy with either agent.
在治疗严重心绞痛患者方面,β受体阻滞剂与钙拮抗剂联合治疗已被证明优于这两类药物中的任何一种单一疗法。这些药物的某些组合会导致不良反应的发生率增加。尽管纳多洛尔和地尔硫䓬作为单一疗法时副作用发生率较低,但关于它们的联合使用情况却知之甚少。因此,将18例尽管接受了药物治疗仍有心绞痛的患者随机分配,分别接受为期3周的纳多洛尔(160毫克/天)、地尔硫䓬(240毫克/天)或二者联合治疗。在每个治疗期结束时,进行平板运动试验以及静息和峰值自行车运动二维超声心动图检查。与单独使用纳多洛尔或地尔硫䓬的单一疗法相比,联合治疗在平板运动峰值时心率-收缩压乘积下降最多(分别为12 vs 14 vs 22×10³,p<0.05)。三种治疗方案的运动持续时间没有差异,但联合治疗组运动期间无心绞痛的患者数量低于单独使用纳多洛尔或地尔硫䓬组(分别为5、10和11例,p<0.05);运动心电图出现1毫米ST段压低的患者数量也有类似结果(分别为6、10和13例,p<0.05)。三种治疗方法在静息和运动峰值时的左心室射血分数相似。纳多洛尔和地尔硫䓬的联合治疗耐受性良好,与单一使用任何一种药物相比,运动期间心肌缺血的证据更少。