Lewis Tom, Doyle David Matthew, Barreto Manuela, Jackson Debby
University of Exeter, Department of Psychology, Washington Singer Laboratories, Perry Road, EX4 4QG, UK.
University of Exeter, Department of Psychology, Washington Singer Laboratories, Perry Road, EX4 4QG, UK.
Soc Sci Med. 2021 Aug;282:114143. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2021.114143. Epub 2021 Jun 17.
Social relationships are important in bolstering health and well-being for everyone in the general population. For transgender people, strong supportive social relationships may be paramount to their overall health and well-being due to their marginalised status in society.
This review aimed to investigate what is currently known about the social relationship experiences of transgender people and their relational partners (e.g., family members, romantic partners).
Thirty-nine qualitative papers were extracted from Web of Science, Scopus, Cochrane, and PubMed that related to social relationships of transgender people. These papers were analysed via a qualitative meta-synthesis.
Forty-nine second-order themes were identified, initially organised into relational partner clusters (e.g., family, friends, work colleagues) for specific phenomena, then these were synthesized into five overarching conceptual themes: (1) Development of relationships through transition and beyond, (2) Coping strategies of transgender people and their relational partners, (3) Reciprocal support in social relationships, (4) Stigma enacted and ameliorated interpersonally, and (5) Influence of stigma on social health and well-being.
These overarching themes show the potential characteristics that assist in the health-buffering role of social relationships for transgender people and their relational partners. Of particular note, stigma was reported as a common negative experience by transgender people and their relational partners, and open communicative social relationships had positive effects on self-conceptualisations of identity, which were inferred to protect against the damaging effects of stigma. We discuss the various implications and applications of this meta-synthesis to future research and clinical settings as well as how it can inform healthcare policy to support transgender people.
社会关系对于普通人群中每个人的健康和幸福都很重要。对于跨性别者而言,由于他们在社会中的边缘地位,强大的支持性社会关系对其整体健康和幸福可能至关重要。
本综述旨在调查目前关于跨性别者及其关系伙伴(如家庭成员、恋爱伴侣)的社会关系经历的已知情况。
从科学网、Scopus、考科蓝图书馆和PubMed中提取了39篇与跨性别者社会关系相关的定性研究论文。这些论文通过定性元综合分析进行分析。
确定了49个二阶主题,最初针对特定现象按关系伙伴类别(如家庭、朋友、同事)进行组织,然后将这些主题综合为五个总体概念主题:(1)过渡期间及之后人际关系的发展,(2)跨性别者及其关系伙伴的应对策略,(3)社会关系中的相互支持,(4)人际间施加和减轻的污名,(5)污名对社会健康和幸福的影响。
这些总体主题显示了有助于社会关系对跨性别者及其关系伙伴发挥健康缓冲作用的潜在特征。特别值得注意的是,污名被报告为跨性别者及其关系伙伴常见的负面经历,开放的交流性社会关系对身份的自我认知有积极影响,据推测这可防止污名的破坏性影响。我们讨论了这种元综合分析对未来研究和临床环境的各种影响及应用,以及它如何为支持跨性别者的医疗政策提供信息。