Tan Kyle K H, Treharne Gareth J, Ellis Sonja J, Schmidt Johanna M, Veale Jaimie F
School of Psychology, University of Waikato, Hamilton, New Zealand.
Department of Psychology, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand.
Int J Transgend Health. 2020 Oct 12;22(3):269-280. doi: 10.1080/15532739.2020.1819504. eCollection 2021.
International evidence has found large mental health inequities among transgender people and demonstrates that mental health outcomes are associated with enacted stigma experiences and protective factors. This study aimed to examine the extent of associations of enacted stigma experiences specific to transgender people alongside protective factors with mental health of transgender people in Aotearoa/New Zealand.
The 2018 Counting Ourselves survey was a nationwide community-based study of transgender people ( = 1178, age = 29.5) living in Aotearoa/New Zealand. The survey assessed a wide range of gender minority stress experiences and protective factors that comprised primary (support from friends and family) and secondary social ties (neighborhood and transgender community belongingness). We calculated the predicted probabilities that transgender people exhibit very high psychological distress level, non-suicidal self-injury, and suicidal risks with different combinations and exposure profiles of enacted stigma and protective factors.
Our findings demonstrated that enacted stigma was associated with negative mental health, and support of friends and family was linked to better outcomes across all mental health measures. Beyond primary social ties, sense of belongingness to neighborhood and transgender communities were linked to reduced odds of psychological distress and suicidal ideation. For those scoring high on enacted stigma and low on protective factors, our model revealed a 25% probability of attempting suicide in the last year compared to 3% for those scoring low on enacted stigma and high on protective factors.
Echoing previous findings, this study demonstrates that transgender people across Aotearoa/New Zealand are less likely to manifest life-threatening mental health outcomes if they experience low levels of enacted stigma and high levels of access to protective factors. Our findings suggest a need to address the enacted stigma that transgender people face across interpersonal and structural settings, and also to enhance social supports that are gender affirmative for this population.
国际证据表明,跨性别者中存在严重的心理健康不平等现象,且心理健康结果与遭受的污名经历和保护因素有关。本研究旨在探讨新西兰奥塔哥/新西兰跨性别者所特有的遭受污名经历以及保护因素与心理健康之间的关联程度。
2018年的“清点我们自己”调查是一项针对生活在新西兰奥塔哥/新西兰的跨性别者(n = 1178,年龄 = 29.5岁)的全国性社区研究。该调查评估了广泛的性别少数群体压力经历和保护因素,包括主要(来自朋友和家人的支持)和次要社会关系(邻里关系和跨性别社区归属感)。我们计算了跨性别者在不同的遭受污名和保护因素组合及暴露情况下表现出极高心理困扰水平、非自杀性自伤和自杀风险的预测概率。
我们的研究结果表明,遭受污名与负面心理健康相关,而朋友和家人的支持与所有心理健康指标的较好结果相关。除了主要社会关系外,邻里和跨性别社区的归属感与心理困扰和自杀意念的几率降低有关。对于那些遭受污名得分高而保护因素得分低的人,我们的模型显示,去年有25%的自杀未遂概率,而对于那些遭受污名得分低且保护因素得分高的人,这一概率为3%。
与之前的研究结果一致,本研究表明,在新西兰奥塔哥/新西兰,如果跨性别者遭受的污名程度较低且获得的保护因素水平较高,他们出现危及生命的心理健康结果的可能性较小。我们的研究结果表明,有必要解决跨性别者在人际和结构环境中面临的遭受污名问题,同时加强对这一群体具有性别肯定作用的社会支持。