Center of Palliative Medicine, Münster University Hospital, Münster, Germany; Clinic for Anesthesiology, Intensive Care Medicine and Acute Pain Therapy, BG University Hospital Bergmannsheil, Bochum, Germany.
Dtsch Arztebl Int. 2021 May 17;118(19):331-338. doi: 10.3238/arztebl.m2021.0124.
The largest German study on place of death was performed for deaths in selected regions of Westphalia in the years 2001 and 2011. In the period thereafter, provision of palliative care was regionally expanded. This upgrade included the establishment of palliative medicine consultation services (PMCS), combining general and specialized palliative care on an outpatient basis. A follow-up place of death survey took place in 2017. The aim was to depict the trends in place of death between 2001 and 2017. A second goal was to determine how often outpatient PMCS were used by persons who died in 2017.
Descriptive analysis of place of death as specified in all death certificates (2001, 2011, 2017) issued in the cities of Bochum and Münster and the districts of Borken and Coesfeld. Comparison of pseudonymized data on deceased patients (2017) treated by the PMCS of Münster and Coesfeld with the place of death database to ascertain the rate of PMCS care at the end of life.
A total of 38 954 death certificates were analyzed, and 5887 deaths were compared with PCMS data. The distribution of place of death was as follows: (2001, 2011, 2017; age standardized; %): own residence 27.8; 23.3; 21.3; hospital: 55.8; 51.8; 51.8; palliative care unit: 0.0; 1.0; 6.2; hospice: 1.9; 4.5; 4.8; nursing home: 13.1; 18.6; 20.4; other: 1.2; 1.2; 1.5. The rate of PMCS use was 28.8% (1694/5887).
Over the period 2001-2017, the proportion of people who died at home or in the hospital went down, while the number who died in a palliative care unit, hospice, or nursing home increased. In the city of Münster and the district of Coesfeld, one fourth of the people who died in 2017 received PMCS care at the end of life.
德国最大的死亡地点研究是在 2001 年和 2011 年对威斯特伐利亚选定地区的死亡进行的。此后,姑息治疗的提供在区域内得到了扩展。这一升级包括建立姑息治疗咨询服务(PMCS),将普通和专门的姑息治疗结合起来,提供门诊服务。2017 年进行了后续的死亡地点调查。目的是描述 2001 年至 2017 年期间死亡地点的趋势。第二个目标是确定 2017 年去世的人中有多少人经常使用门诊 PMCS。
对博霍姆和明斯特市以及博肯和科菲尔德区所有死亡证明(2001 年、2011 年、2017 年)中指定的死亡地点进行描述性分析。比较明斯特和科菲尔德 PMCS 治疗的已故患者(2017 年)的匿名数据与死亡地点数据库,以确定临终时 PMCS 护理的比率。
共分析了 38954 份死亡证明,比较了 5887 份死亡证明与 PMCS 数据。死亡地点的分布如下:(2001 年、2011 年、2017 年;年龄标准化;%):自有住所 27.8;23.3;21.3;医院 55.8;51.8;51.8;姑息治疗病房 0.0;1.0;6.2;临终关怀院 1.9;4.5;4.8;养老院 13.1;18.6;20.4;其他 1.2;1.2;1.5。PMCS 使用率为 28.8%(1694/5887)。
在 2001-2017 年期间,在家中或医院死亡的人数比例下降,而在姑息治疗病房、临终关怀院或养老院死亡的人数增加。在明斯特市和科菲尔德区,2017 年去世的四分之一的人在生命末期接受了 PMCS 护理。