Schray M F, Martinez A, Howes A E, Podratz K C, Ballon S C, Malkasian G D, Sikic B I
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN 55905.
J Clin Oncol. 1988 Sep;6(9):1433-9. doi: 10.1200/JCO.1988.6.9.1433.
Between 1979 and 1984, 53 patients received whole abdominal irradiation in a curative salvage effort for residual (32 patients) or recurrent (21 patients) epithelial ovarian cancer after combination chemotherapy (cisplatin-based in 48 patients). Residual cancer less than or equal to 2 cm in diameter was confirmed at operation in all patients before irradiation consisting of 2,550 to 3,000 rad to the whole abdomen with partial liver/kidney shielding and boosting of the dose to the diaphragmatic/paraaortic nodal regions and pelvis to approximately 4,000 and 5,000 rad, respectively. Twelve patients (23%) did not complete therapy as a result of hematologic intolerance. Actuarial overall and disease-free survival at 3 years are 35% and 30%, respectively, with follow-up for disease-free patients ranging from 30 to 79 months (median, 43 months). Twenty-seven of 36 relapses (75%) occurred within the irradiated abdomen alone. At 3 years, 70% of patients with well- or moderately-differentiated tumors were disease-free v 10% of those with poorly differentiated tumors (P less than .001). Among prognostic factors evaluated, including grade, initial residual disease before chemotherapy, residual disease at time of irradiation, age, chemotherapy response v progression, and completion of irradiation, only grade and initial residual disease before chemotherapy were statistically significant in multivariate analysis (both P less than .01). Patients with the combination of high-grade tumor, initial residual disease greater than 2 cm before chemotherapy, and macroscopic disease after "second-look" laparotomy do not benefit from irradiation. Eleven patients (21%) developed an apparent treatment-related bowel obstruction after completion of irradiation. Selected subsets of patients do well; however, the role of irradiation in this setting can be confirmed only with randomized clinical study.
1979年至1984年间,53例患者接受了全腹照射,作为对联合化疗(48例以顺铂为基础)后残留(32例)或复发(21例)上皮性卵巢癌进行挽救性根治的一种手段。在所有患者放疗前手术中均证实残留癌直径小于或等于2 cm,全腹照射剂量为2550至3000拉德,部分肝脏/肾脏进行屏蔽,同时将膈下/腹主动脉旁淋巴结区域和盆腔的剂量分别增加至约4000和5000拉德。12例患者(23%)因血液学不耐受未完成治疗。3年时的精算总生存率和无病生存率分别为35%和30%,无病患者的随访时间为30至79个月(中位数为43个月)。36例复发患者中有27例(75%)仅发生在照射的腹部内。3年时,高分化或中分化肿瘤患者70%无病,而低分化肿瘤患者为10%(P<0.001)。在评估的预后因素中,包括分级、化疗前初始残留疾病、放疗时残留疾病、年龄、化疗反应与进展以及放疗完成情况,多因素分析中仅分级和化疗前初始残留疾病具有统计学意义(均P<0.01)。肿瘤分级高、化疗前初始残留疾病大于2 cm且“二次探查”剖腹术后有肉眼可见疾病的患者无法从放疗中获益。11例患者(21%)在放疗完成后出现明显的与治疗相关的肠梗阻。部分特定患者亚组预后良好;然而,仅通过随机临床研究才能证实放疗在此情况下的作用。