From the Department of Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, University Hospital Bonn, Venusberg-Campus 1, 53127 Bonn, Germany (C.H.E., D.G., A.I., A.F., N.M., D.K., C.C.P., P.A.K., U.I.A., J.A.L.); and Quantitative Imaging Laboratory Bonn (QILaB), Bonn, Germany (C.H.E., A.I., A.F., N.M., D.K., P.A.K., J.A.L.).
Radiology. 2021 Sep;300(3):633-640. doi: 10.1148/radiol.2021204187. Epub 2021 Jun 29.
Background Cervical spine CT is regularly performed to exclude cervical spine injury during the initial evaluation of trauma patients. Patients with asymmetry of the lateral atlantodental interval (LADI) often undergo subsequent MRI to rule out ligamentous injuries. The clinical relevance of an asymmetric LADI and the benefit of additional MRI remain unclear. Purpose To evaluate the diagnostic benefit of additional MRI in patients with blunt trauma who have asymmetry of the LADI and no other cervical injuries. Materials and Methods Patients who underwent cervical spine CT during initial trauma evaluation between March 2017 and August 2019 were retrospectively evaluated. Those who underwent subsequent MRI because of LADI asymmetry of 1 mm or greater with no other signs of cervical injury were identified and reevaluated by two readers blinded to clinical data and initial study reports regarding possible ligamentous injuries. Results Among 1553 patients, 146 (9%) had LADI asymmetry of 1 mm or greater. Of these, 46 patients (mean age ± standard deviation, 39 years ± 22; 28 men; median LADI asymmetry, 2.4 mm [interquartile range, 1.8-3.1 mm]) underwent supplementary MRI with no other signs of cervical injury at initial CT. Ten of the 46 patients (22%) showed cervical tenderness at clinical examination, and 36 patients (78%) were asymptomatic. In two of the 46 patients (4%), MRI revealed alar ligament injury; both of these patients showed LADI asymmetry greater than 3 mm, along with cervical tenderness at clinical examination, and underwent treatment for ligamentous injury. In 13 of the 46 patients (28%), signal intensity alterations of alar ligaments without signs of rupture were observed. Four of these 13 patients (31%) were subsequently treated for ligamentous injury despite being asymptomatic. Conclusion Subsequent MRI following CT of the cervical spine in trauma patients with lateral atlantodental interval asymmetry may have diagnostic benefit only in symptomatic patients. In asymptomatic patients without proven cervical injuries, subsequent MRI showed no diagnostic benefit and may even lead to overtreatment. © RSNA, 2021
背景 颈椎 CT 常用于排除创伤患者颈椎损伤。外侧寰齿间距(LADI)不对称的患者通常会进一步接受 MRI 检查以排除韧带损伤。LADI 不对称的临床相关性和额外 MRI 的获益仍不清楚。目的 评估颈椎 CT 检查显示无其他颈椎损伤但 LADI 不对称的钝性创伤患者行额外 MRI 的诊断获益。材料与方法 回顾性分析 2017 年 3 月至 2019 年 8 月间行颈椎 CT 检查的患者。因 LADI 不对称≥1mm 且无其他颈椎损伤征象而接受 MRI 检查的患者被识别并由 2 位对临床数据和初始研究报告中有关可能存在的韧带损伤的信息均不知情的读者重新评估。结果 在 1553 例患者中,146 例(9%)的 LADI 不对称≥1mm。其中,46 例(平均年龄±标准差,39 岁±22 岁;28 例男性;中位 LADI 不对称,2.4mm[四分位数间距,1.8~3.1mm])行初始 CT 检查未见其他颈椎损伤征象后行补充 MRI 检查。46 例患者中有 10 例(22%)在体格检查时存在颈椎压痛,36 例(78%)无症状。在这 46 例患者中,有 2 例(4%)的 MRI 显示翼状韧带损伤;这 2 例患者的 LADI 不对称均大于 3mm,同时体格检查时存在颈椎压痛,行韧带损伤治疗。在这 46 例患者中,有 13 例(28%)观察到翼状韧带信号强度改变但无断裂征象。这 13 例患者中有 4 例(31%)尽管无症状,但随后接受了韧带损伤治疗。结论 颈椎 CT 检查显示 LADI 不对称的创伤患者行 CT 后进一步行 MRI 检查可能仅对有症状的患者有诊断获益。无症状且无明确颈椎损伤的患者,进一步 MRI 检查无诊断获益,甚至可能导致过度治疗。 © RSNA,2021