Steve Hicks School of Social Work, The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX, USA.
Fam Process. 2022 Jun;61(2):873-889. doi: 10.1111/famp.12685. Epub 2021 Jun 30.
Current U.S. immigration policies disproportionately impact Mexican-origin mixed-status families, yet few studies examine the consequences of immigration enforcement (e.g., immigration-related arrest and detention) and deportation on sibling dynamics. Given this gap, this study focuses on the experiences and changes within sibling relationships in the aftermath of parental detention and deportation. We analyzed a subsample of 20 citizen children interviews (7 sibling dyads; 2 sibling triads) from a multi-site binational study that examined the psychosocial functioning of U.S. citizen children with undocumented Mexican parents. Using inductive thematic analysis, we explored the roles and functional importance of sibling relationships before and after experiences of parents' detention and deportation. Our findings suggest that prior to detention or deportation experiences, sibling relationships were described as "normal." After these experiences, however, sibling relationships changed and developed protective adaptations, including more open communication about their experiences and the assumption of caregiving roles. In cases where deportation did not occur, there still existed the threat of future immigration-related action, which contributed to fear and an inability to share feelings and experiences among siblings. Our findings suggest that sibling relationships might serve as an important locus of stability and protection. Yet, adaptive communication may not emerge as long as the threat of apprehension, detention, and deportation exists.
当前的美国移民政策不成比例地影响了墨西哥裔混合身份家庭,但很少有研究考察移民执法(例如,与移民相关的逮捕和拘留)和驱逐出境对兄弟姐妹关系的影响。鉴于这一差距,本研究关注的是父母被拘留和被驱逐出境后兄弟姐妹关系的经历和变化。我们分析了一项多地点跨国研究的 20 名公民子女访谈(7 对兄弟姐妹;2 个兄弟姐妹三人组)的子样本,该研究考察了有 undocumented 墨西哥父母的美国公民子女的心理社会功能。使用归纳主题分析,我们探讨了父母被拘留和被驱逐出境前后兄弟姐妹关系的角色和功能重要性。我们的研究结果表明,在拘留或驱逐出境经历之前,兄弟姐妹关系被描述为“正常”。然而,在这些经历之后,兄弟姐妹关系发生了变化,并发展出了保护性的适应,包括更开放地交流他们的经历和承担照顾者的角色。在没有被驱逐出境的情况下,仍然存在未来与移民相关的行动的威胁,这导致兄弟姐妹之间存在恐惧和无法分享感受和经历。我们的研究结果表明,兄弟姐妹关系可能是一个重要的稳定和保护场所。然而,只要存在被捕、拘留和驱逐出境的威胁,适应性交流就可能不会出现。