UHN Cardiovascular Prevention and Rehabilitation Program, Toronto, Ontario, CA.
Shanghai Xinhua Hospital, affiliated to Shanghai Jiaotong University School of Medicine, Shanghai, CN.
Glob Heart. 2021 Jun 10;16(1):43. doi: 10.5334/gh.939.
We investigated impacts of COVID-19 on cardiac rehabilitation (CR) delivery around the globe, including virtual delivery, as well as effects on providers and patients.
In this cross-sectional study, a piloted survey was administered to CR programs globally via REDCap from April to June 2020. The 50 members of the International Council of Cardiovascular Prevention and Rehabilitation (ICCPR) and personal contacts facilitated program identification.
Overall, 1062 (18.3% program response rate) responses were received from 70/111 (63.1% country response rate) countries in the world with existent CR programs. Of these, 367 (49.1%) programs reported they had stopped CR delivery, and 203 (27.1%) stopped temporarily (mean = 8.3 ± 2.8 weeks). Alternative models were delivered in 322 (39.7%) programs, primarily through low-tech modes (n = 226,19.3%). Furthermore, 353 (30.2%) respondents were re-deployed, and 276 (37.3%) felt the need to work due to fear of losing their job, despite the perceived risk of contracting COVID-19 (mean = 30.0% ± 27.4/100). Also, 266 (22.5%) reported anxiety, 241(20.4%) were concerned about exposing their family, 113 (9.7%) reported increased workload to transition to remote delivery, and 105 (9.0%) were juggling caregiving responsibilities during business hours. Patients were often contacting staff regarding grocery shopping for heart-healthy foods (n = 333, 28.4%), how to use technology to interact with the program (n = 329, 27.9%), having to stop their exercise because they have no place to exercise (n = 303, 25.7%), and their risk of death from COVID-19 due to pre-existing cardiovascular disease (n = 249, 21.2%). Respondents perceived staff (n = 488, 41.3%) and patient (n = 453, 38.6%) personal protective equipment, as well as COVID-19 screening (n = 414, 35.2%), and testing (n = 411, 35.0%) as paramount to in-person service resumption.
Given the estimated number of CR programs globally, these results suggest approximately 4400 CR programs globally have ceased or temporarily stopped service delivery. Those that remain open are implementing new technologies to ensure their patients receive CR safely, despite the challenges.
我们调查了 COVID-19 对全球心脏康复 (CR) 服务的影响,包括虚拟服务,以及对提供者和患者的影响。
在这项横断面研究中,通过 REDCap 向全球 CR 项目进行了试点调查,时间为 2020 年 4 月至 6 月。国际心血管预防与康复理事会 (ICCPR) 的 50 名成员和个人联系人协助确定了项目。
来自全球 70 个国家/地区的 111 个国家/地区(63.1%的国家/地区参与率)的 1062 个(18.3%的项目参与率)项目做出了回应。其中,367 个(49.1%)项目报告已停止 CR 服务,203 个(27.1%)项目暂时停止(平均=8.3±2.8 周)。322 个(39.7%)项目采用了替代模式,主要通过低技术模式(n=226,19.3%)。此外,353 名(30.2%)受访者被重新部署,276 名(37.3%)由于担心失业而感到有必要工作,尽管他们认为感染 COVID-19 的风险(平均=30.0%±27.4/100)。此外,266 名(22.5%)受访者报告焦虑,241 名(20.4%)担心暴露家人,113 名(9.7%)报告说,为了向远程服务过渡,工作量增加,105 名(9.0%)在工作时间内要兼顾护理责任。患者经常就购买心脏健康食品(n=333,28.4%)、如何使用技术与项目互动(n=329,27.9%)、因无处锻炼而不得不停止锻炼(n=303,25.7%)以及因患有心血管疾病而死于 COVID-19 的风险(n=249,21.2%)等问题与工作人员联系。受访者认为工作人员(n=488,41.3%)和患者(n=453,38.6%)的个人防护设备,以及 COVID-19 筛查(n=414,35.2%)和检测(n=411,35.0%)对于恢复面对面服务至关重要。
鉴于全球 CR 项目的估计数量,这些结果表明,全球约有 4400 个 CR 项目已经停止或暂时停止服务提供。那些仍在运营的项目正在采用新技术,以确保其患者安全接受 CR,尽管面临挑战。