Alser Muath, Alkhatib Mo'min, Alnakhala Ahmed, Barhoom Mohammed Ibrahim
Cairo University Faculty of Medicine, Cairo, Egypt.
Cairo University Faculty of Medicine, Cairo, Egypt.
Lancet. 2021 Jul;398 Suppl 1:S10. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(21)01496-3.
In Gaza, 2 million people have been affected by more than 13 years of strict land, air, and sea blockades and three wars, during which over 4000 people have been killed and many more have been injured. Additional severe effects have been seen on lives, aspirations, and prospects. Given the conditions, medical students have many competing reasons for and against studying medicine abroad. We investigated motives, academic situations, and future plans of the upcoming generation of doctors in Gaza, occupied Palestinian territory.
We did a questionnaire-based cross-sectional study involving Palestinian medical students originally from Gaza who were studying at the largest five medical schools in Egypt (Cairo, Ain Shams, Alexandria, Mansoura, and Zagazig Universities). We used a self-designed questionnaire developed from previous similar studies and created on Google Forms (Google, Menlo Park, CA, USA). A pilot study of 37 participants was done to test the comprehensibility of questions and the time needed to complete the questionnaire. After being updated, the questionnaire was distributed in August and September, 2018, to individuals who provided verbal informed decision to participate. Analysis of the results was performed with SPSS version 22.
Of 453 questionnaires given to students, 340 (75%) were returned completed. The mean age of respondents was 21·7 (SD 1·8) years; 225 (66%) were men and 115 (34%) were women. Excellence was achieved in secondary school examinations (result ≥90%) by 315 (93%) of students, but only 26 (8%) of students achieved excellence in their first year of medical school (examination results ≥85%). 317 students (93%) reported that they chose their medical schools independently without pressure from their families. Among the 115 women, 70 (61%) went to a third party to persuade their parents to allow them to study abroad. Of ten motives to study medicine given in the questionnaire, "to relieve pains" and "childhood dream" were the most frequently selected among the 340 respondents, chosen by 228 (67%) and 208 (61%), respectively. 104 (31%) reported they were seeking freedom more than to study medicine. 214 (63%) of students had at least one relative who had been physically injured in or killed during of one of the wars in Gaza. Most students (n=278 [82%]) were delayed from starting at their medical school due to border closures and 189 (56%) had been unable to attend for at least one semester. Since starting at medical school, 269 (79%) of 340 respondents had visited Gaza only once or not at all. 55 (16%) intended never return to Gaza and 209 (62%) reported that they wanted to specialise and work abroad for a period and then return to Gaza. Of the remainder, 64 (19%) wanted to specialise abroad then return to work in Gaza, and 12 (3%) wanted to specialise and work in Gaza.
The motives, academic performance, and career prospects of Gazan medical students studying in Egypt are influenced in many ways by the situation in Gaza, some of which could worsen the already bad condition of medical care in Gaza. Awareness and supportive programmes for Gazan medical students should be encouraged to improve the quality of health care providers in Gaza.
None.
在加沙,200万人受到长达13年多的严格陆地、空中和海上封锁以及三场战争的影响,在此期间,4000多人丧生,更多人受伤。生活、理想和前景也受到了额外的严重影响。鉴于这些情况,医学生有许多支持和反对出国留学的相互矛盾的理由。我们调查了巴勒斯坦被占领土加沙即将成为医生的这一代人的动机、学业情况和未来计划。
我们进行了一项基于问卷调查的横断面研究,涉及最初来自加沙、在埃及最大的五所医学院(开罗大学、艾因夏姆斯大学、亚历山大大学、曼苏拉大学和扎加济格大学)学习的巴勒斯坦医学生。我们使用了一份根据以前类似研究自行设计的问卷,并在谷歌表单(谷歌,美国加利福尼亚州门洛帕克)上创建。对37名参与者进行了预试验,以测试问题的可理解性和完成问卷所需的时间。问卷更新后,于2018年8月和9月分发给提供口头知情同意参与的个人。使用SPSS 22版对结果进行分析。
在发放给学生的453份问卷中,340份(75%)被完整返还。受访者的平均年龄为21.7(标准差1.8)岁;225名(66%)为男性,115名(34%)为女性。315名(93%)学生在中学考试中成绩优异(成绩≥90%),但在医学院第一年成绩优异(考试成绩≥85%)的学生只有26名(8%)。317名学生(93%)报告说,他们是独立选择医学院的,没有受到家人的压力。在115名女性中,70名(61%)找第三方说服父母允许她们出国留学。在问卷给出的十个学医动机中,“减轻痛苦”和“童年梦想”在340名受访者中被选中的频率最高,分别有228名(67%)和208名(61%)选择。104名(31%)报告说,他们寻求的是自由而非学医。214名(63%)学生至少有一名亲属在加沙的一场战争中身体受伤或丧生。大多数学生(n = 278 [82%])因边境关闭而推迟进入医学院,189名(56%)学生至少有一个学期无法入学。自进入医学院以来,340名受访者中有269名(79%)只去过加沙一次或根本没去过。55名(16%)打算永远不回加沙,209名(62%)报告说,他们想在国外专科学习并工作一段时间,然后回到加沙。其余的人中,64名(19%)想在国外专科学习然后回到加沙工作,12名(3%)想在加沙专科学习并工作。
在埃及学习的加沙医学生的动机、学业成绩和职业前景在很多方面受到加沙局势的影响,其中一些可能会使加沙本已糟糕的医疗状况恶化。应鼓励为加沙医学生开展提高认识和支持项目,以改善加沙医疗服务提供者的质量。
无。