Taliaferro Steven L, Harger Beverly L
Steven Taliaferro is an assistant professor in the Basic Sciences Department at the University of Western States College of Chiropractic (2900 NE 132nd Avenue, Portland, OR 97230;
Beverly Harger is the program director, Diagnostic Imaging, University of Western States (2900 NE 132nd Avenue, Portland, OR 97230;
J Chiropr Educ. 2022 Mar 1;36(1):22-29. doi: 10.7899/JCE-19-33.
The goal of this study was to investigate whether blended online with laboratory instruction differs from traditional classroom lecture and laboratory with regard to student satisfaction and performance in a radiographic technique class teaching radiation health and physics.
Following institutional review board approval, 122 participants were randomly assigned to either an online or classroom environment for the lecture portion of the course. All participants attended weekly laboratory sessions in person. Anonymous surveys given during midterm and final exams assessed satisfaction with learning experience and expected grades. Linear models assessing differences between groups were adjusted for age, gender, prior online class experience, online class preference, self-reported computer skill, and time of year.
Students in the blended cohort reported overall greater satisfaction (p < .03) and found the delivery method more enjoyable (p < .002) than did the traditional classroom cohort. No differences in exam scores between groups were observed.
This study demonstrated that a blended format of instruction can improve learner satisfaction as compared with the traditional classroom method. Blended instruction implemented into a traditional educational program helps students balance schedules, has a positive impact on perceived learning, and provides exam success similar to that of the traditional classroom.
本研究的目的是调查在放射技术课程(讲授辐射健康与物理)中,线上与实验室指导相结合的教学方式与传统课堂讲授和实验室教学相比,在学生满意度和成绩方面是否存在差异。
在获得机构审查委员会批准后,122名参与者被随机分配到课程讲授部分的线上或课堂环境中。所有参与者都亲自参加每周的实验课程。在期中考试和期末考试期间进行的匿名调查评估了对学习体验的满意度和预期成绩。评估组间差异的线性模型针对年龄、性别、先前的线上课程经验、线上课程偏好、自我报告的计算机技能和年份进行了调整。
与传统课堂组相比,混合教学组的学生总体满意度更高(p < .03),并且认为教学方式更有趣(p < .002)。未观察到组间考试成绩的差异。
本研究表明,与传统课堂教学方法相比,混合教学模式可以提高学习者的满意度。将混合教学模式应用于传统教育项目有助于学生平衡日程安排,对感知学习有积极影响,并能提供与传统课堂相似的考试成绩。