Department of Biology, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA 52242, USA.
Department of Gender, Women's, and Sexuality Studies, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA 52242, USA.
Proc Biol Sci. 2021 Jul 14;288(1954):20211248. doi: 10.1098/rspb.2021.1248.
Preprints are manuscripts posted on a public server that do not yet have formal certification of peer review from a scholarly journal. The increasingly prominent online repositories for these preprints provide a means of rapidly making scientific results accessible to all with an Internet connection. We here describe the catalysis and subsequent development of a successful new process to solicit preprints for consideration for publication in We present preliminary comparisons between the focal topics and geographic origin of submitting authors of papers submitted in the traditional (non-solicited) route versus solicited preprints. This analysis suggests that the solicitation process seems to be achieving one of the primary goals of the preprint solicitation endeavour: broadening the scope of the papers featured in . We also use an informal survey of the early-career scientists that are or have been involved with the Preprint Editorial Team to find that these scientists view their participation positively with respect to career development and knowledge in their field. The inclusion of early-career researchers from across the world in the preprint solicitation process could also translate into social justice benefits by providing a career-building opportunity and a window into the publishing process for young scientists.
预印本是指发布在公共服务器上的手稿,尚未经过学术期刊的同行评审正式认证。这些预印本的在线存储库越来越多,为所有有互联网连接的人提供了一种快速获取科学成果的途径。我们在这里描述了一个成功的新流程的催化和后续发展,该流程旨在征集预印本来考虑在 上发表。我们展示了传统(非征求)途径投稿与征求预印本投稿的作者的焦点主题和地理来源之间的初步比较。这项分析表明,征求过程似乎实现了预印本征求工作的主要目标之一:扩大 上发表的论文的范围。我们还对参与预印本编辑团队的早期职业科学家进行了非正式调查,发现这些科学家对他们在职业发展和领域知识方面的参与持积极态度。通过为年轻科学家提供职业发展机会和进入出版过程的窗口,将世界各地的早期职业研究人员纳入预印本征求过程也可能带来社会正义方面的好处。