Nathan Rajan, Gabbay Mark, Boyle Sean, Elliott Phil, Giebel Clarissa, O'Loughlin Carl, Wilson Pete, Saini Pooja
Cheshire and Wirral Partnership NHS Foundation Trust, Chester, United Kingdom.
NIHR CLAHRC NWC, Liverpool, United Kingdom.
Front Psychiatry. 2021 Jun 28;12:696478. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2021.696478. eCollection 2021.
Human decision-making involves a complex interplay of intra- and inter-personal factors. The decisions clinicians make in practise are subject to a wide range of influences. Admission to a psychiatric hospital is a major clinical intervention, but the decision-making processes involved in admissions remain unclear. To delineate the range of factors influencing clinicians' decisions to arrange acute psychiatric admissions. We undertook six focus groups with teams centrally involved in decisions to admit patients to hospital (crisis resolution home treatment, liaison psychiatry, approved mental health practitioners and consultant psychiatrists). The data were analysed using qualitative thematic analysis. Our analysis of the data show a complex range of factors influencing decision-making that were categorised as those related to: (i) clinical and risk factors; (ii) fear/threat factors; (iii) interpersonal dynamics; (iv) contextual factors. Decisions to arrange acute admission to hospital are not just based on an appraisal of clinical and risk-related information. Emotional, interpersonal and contextual factors are also critical in decision-making. Delineating the breadth of factors that bear on clinical decision-making can inform approaches to (i) clinical decision-making research, (ii) the training and supervision of clinicians, and (iii) service delivery models.
人类决策涉及个人内部和人际间因素的复杂相互作用。临床医生在实践中做出的决策会受到广泛影响。入住精神病医院是一项重大的临床干预措施,但入院决策过程仍不明确。为了明确影响临床医生安排急性精神病入院决策的因素范围,我们与集中参与患者入院决策的团队(危机解决家庭治疗团队、联络精神病学团队、核准精神科医生和精神科顾问医生)进行了六个焦点小组讨论。使用定性主题分析法对数据进行了分析。我们对数据的分析显示,影响决策的因素复杂多样,可分为以下几类:(i)临床和风险因素;(ii)恐惧/威胁因素;(iii)人际动态;(iv)背景因素。安排急性入院的决策不仅仅基于对临床和风险相关信息的评估。情感、人际和背景因素在决策中也至关重要。明确影响临床决策的因素范围可为以下方面提供参考:(i)临床决策研究;(ii)临床医生的培训和监督;(iii)服务提供模式。