National Rare Diseases Office, Mater Misericordiae University Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
Centre of Genomics and Policy, Department of Human Genetics, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada.
J Genet Couns. 2022 Feb;31(1):49-58. doi: 10.1002/jgc4.1468. Epub 2021 Jul 15.
Genetic counseling is a fast-growing profession in Canada. Yet, despite its growth, genetic counseling lacks legal recognition in the majority of Canadian provinces. Legal recognition serves to regulate professions, including genetic counseling, that if not properly regulated, expose the public to the risk of harm. Under Canadian law, there are three models of legal recognition: 1) the constitution of a professional order, 2) inclusion in a professional order, and 3) delegation. This paper explores the practical implications of these different models of legal recognition for genetic counselors. It focuses on the balancing act between protecting the public and the resources required to seek legal recognition under the three different models. With a small number of genetic counselors (n = 484, with 89% found in 4 provinces) compared to other professions, the route toward professional regulation for genetic counselors can be challenging. Though legal recognition occurs at the provincial rather than federal level in Canada, we nonetheless advocate for pan-Canadian discussions that may benefit future pursuits of legal recognition.
遗传咨询在加拿大是一个快速发展的职业。然而,尽管其发展迅速,但在加拿大大多数省份,遗传咨询缺乏法律认可。法律认可的目的是对包括遗传咨询在内的专业进行监管,如果这些专业得不到适当的监管,公众就有可能面临伤害的风险。根据加拿大法律,有三种法律认可模式:1)组建专业机构,2)纳入专业机构,3)授权。本文探讨了这些不同法律认可模式对遗传咨询师的实际影响。它侧重于在保护公众和寻求三种不同模式下法律认可所需的资源之间取得平衡。与其他专业相比,遗传咨询师的数量较少(n=484,其中 89%在 4 个省找到),因此遗传咨询师的专业监管途径可能具有挑战性。尽管在加拿大,法律认可发生在省级而不是联邦一级,但我们仍主张进行全加讨论,这可能有助于未来寻求法律认可。