Is 3D laparoscopic off clamp simple enucleation a feasible alternative for clinical T1 renal tumors? Outcomes from a single center experience.

PURPOSE

To evaluate the safety of 3D laparoscopic off clamp simple enucleation (SE) of kidney tumors versus standard laparoscopic on-clamp partial nephrectomy (PN) in terms of perioperative, oncological and functional outcomes.

METHODS

All patients that underwent 3D laparoscopic nephron sparing surgery (NSS) in our department for clinical T1 tumors between January 2019-September 2020 were included. Of the total of 84 patients, 38 (45.24%) underwent SE (SE group) and 46 (54.76%) PN (PN group). Perioperative data was collected and analyzed. Oncological outcomes were evaluated by the positive surgical margin (PSM) rate and follow-up at 6 months after surgery.

RESULTS

Mean age, gender, tumor size, PADUA score and length of hospital stay were comparable between the two groups. Estimated intraoperative blood loss (284.21 ml vs 151.52 ml, p=0.0001) and hemoglobin drop (p=0.0001) were significantly lower for the PN group. Patients that underwent SE showed a better preservation of renal function (eGFR drop of 4.4 ml/min vs 1.78 ml/min, p=0.75). No significant differences were found regarding the PSM, although the PSM rate was lower in the SE group when compared with the PN group (2.63% vs 4.34%, p= 0.07).

CONCLUSION

Off-clamp simple enucleation of renal masses is feasible by laparoscopic approach and has produced comparable oncologic outcomes with standard on-clamp partial nephrectomy, with an incremental advantage for the preservation of renal function.