Massachusetts General Hospital/Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, PA, USA.
Pituitary. 2022 Feb;25(1):64-73. doi: 10.1007/s11102-021-01170-3. Epub 2021 Jul 20.
In adults and children, transsphenoidal surgery (TSS) represents the cornerstone of management for most large or functioning sellar lesions with the exception of prolactinomas. Endocrine evaluation and management are an essential part of perioperative care. However, the details of endocrine assessment and care are not universally agreed upon.
To build consensus on the endocrine evaluation and management of adults undergoing TSS, a Delphi process was used. Thirty-five statements were developed by the Pituitary Society's Education Committee. Fifty-five pituitary endocrinologists, all members of the Pituitary Society, were invited to participate in two Delphi rounds and rate their extent of agreement with statements pertaining to perioperative endocrine evaluation and management, using a Likert-type scale. Anonymized data on the proportion of panelists' agreeing with each item were summarized. A list of items that achieved consensus, based on predefined criteria, was tabulated.
Strong consensus (≥ 80% of panelists rating their agreement as 6-7 on a scale from 1 to 7) was achieved for 68.6% (24/35) items. If less strict agreement criteria were applied (ratings 5-7 on the Likert-type scale), consensus was achieved for 88% (31/35) items.
We achieved consensus on a large majority of items pertaining to perioperative endocrine evaluation and management using a Delphi process. This provides an international real-world clinical perspective from an expert group and facilitates a framework for future guideline development. Some of the items for which consensus was not reached, including the assessment of immediate postoperative remission in acromegaly or Cushing's disease, represent areas where further research is needed.
在成人和儿童中,经蝶窦手术(TSS)是大多数大型或功能性鞍区病变(除泌乳素瘤外)的主要治疗方法。内分泌评估和管理是围手术期护理的重要组成部分。然而,内分泌评估和管理的细节并未得到普遍认可。
为了就接受 TSS 的成年人的内分泌评估和管理达成共识,采用了 Delphi 流程。垂体学会教育委员会制定了 35 项声明。邀请了 55 名垂体内分泌学家(均为垂体学会成员)参加两轮 Delphi 投票,对与围手术期内分泌评估和管理相关的声明表示同意程度,使用李克特量表进行评分。汇总了每位小组成员对每项内容的同意比例的匿名数据。根据预设标准列出达成共识的项目清单。
对于 68.6%(24/35)的项目,强烈一致(≥80%的小组成员对 1 到 7 的量表评分 6-7)。如果应用较宽松的同意标准(李克特量表的评分 5-7),则有 88%(31/35)的项目达成共识。
我们使用 Delphi 流程就大多数与围手术期内分泌评估和管理相关的项目达成了共识。这从专家小组提供了国际现实世界的临床视角,并为未来指南的制定提供了框架。一些未达成共识的项目,包括对肢端肥大症或库欣病患者术后即刻缓解的评估,代表了需要进一步研究的领域。