Stroud, Gloucestershire, UK.
Curr Opin Endocrinol Diabetes Obes. 2021 Oct 1;28(5):453-462. doi: 10.1097/MED.0000000000000666.
The objective of this study was to test the feasibility of exercising over a 5-day period while fasting, in those with and without type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1DM).Eight individuals, ages 29--62 years, two with T1DM, walked/ran around 20 miles per day for five consecutive days while only consuming water. All eight individuals completed the project with no physical injuries or problems with diabetes control. The blood glucose levels ranged from less than 3 mmol/l to 7 mmol/l in those without T1D, and less than 3 mmol/l to 9 mmol/l in those with T1D. The continuous glucose traces in those with T1D showed little variability in glucose levels. The participants without T1D had no symptoms from blood glucose under 3 mmol/l. Ketone levels ranged from 0.3 to 7.5 and the ketones for those with T1D were no different to ketones in those without T1D. The respiratory quotient was overwhelmingly in the fat-burning range. There was very little subjective hunger, nor did it negatively affect mood. In keto-adapted individuals, with or without T1DM, prolonged exercise for 5 days while in nutritional ketosis was feasible, and well tolerated.
Eight adults, ages 28-62 years, trained for and completed a 5-day zero calorie fast covering 100 miles over 5 days. Training involved each individual preparing for the event according to their own programme. Typically, it involved both cardiovascular and strength training with the addition of practice water only fasts over 24-72 h or more based upon the individual's assessment of what was needed to complete the event. There was no formal protocol provided for this. The recommendation was that the participants would be keto adapted and trained to a level sufficient to complete the 5-day event. Keto adaptation was measured by ketone blood testing of betahydroxybutyrate. Two people had type 1 diabetes. All but one person was keto-adapted ahead of the event. All eight individuals completed the project with no physical injuries or problems with diabetes control. Prolonged fasting did neither lead to hunger nor did it negatively affect mood, which, if anything, was enhanced in most individuals. All keto-adapted people were shown to be burning fat stores throughout the 5 days, and everyone was measured to be in a state of nutritional ketosis. In type 1 diabetes, and ketones were in the same range as those without diabetes, insulin volumes were considerably reduced, and glucose control was close to physiological: nutritional ketosis is not a risk factor for diabetic ketoacidosis; consumption of sugar for energy is not required for distances of up to 100 miles in keto-adapted people; people who inject insulin do not necessarily need to consume carbohydrates unless rescuing a hypoglycaemic attack.
The findings from this project should provide reassurance to those clinicians who want to provide the option of a ketogenic lifestyle to their patients with type 1 diabetes. They also confirm that the fat stores are available for aerobic respiration without apparent negative consequences on physical or mental function.
本研究旨在测试在禁食 5 天期间进行锻炼的可行性,对象为 1 型糖尿病(T1DM)患者和非 T1DM 患者。8 名年龄在 29-62 岁的参与者,其中 2 名为 T1DM 患者,连续 5 天每天行走/跑步约 20 英里,期间仅摄入水。所有 8 名参与者均完成了项目,无身体损伤或糖尿病控制问题。非 T1D 患者的血糖水平在 3mmol/L 以下至 7mmol/L 之间,T1D 患者的血糖水平在 3mmol/L 以下至 9mmol/L 之间。T1D 患者的连续血糖轨迹显示血糖水平变化不大。非 T1D 患者的血糖水平低于 3mmol/L 时没有任何症状。酮体水平在 0.3 至 7.5 之间,T1D 患者的酮体与非 T1D 患者的酮体没有区别。呼吸商绝大多数处于脂肪燃烧范围。参与者几乎没有主观饥饿感,也没有对情绪产生负面影响。在适应酮体的个体中,无论是否患有 T1DM,在营养性酮症状态下进行长达 5 天的长时间运动是可行且耐受良好的。
8 名成年人,年龄在 28-62 岁之间,接受了为期 5 天的零卡路里禁食训练,在此期间完成了 100 英里的路程。训练包括每个参与者根据自己的计划为活动做准备。通常情况下,它涉及心血管和力量训练,以及根据个人需要进行 24-72 小时或更长时间的水禁食练习,以适应个人完成活动的需要。对此没有正式的协议。建议参与者适应酮体并训练到足以完成 5 天活动的水平。酮体适应通过检测 betahydroxybutyrate 的酮体血液测试来衡量。其中 2 人为 1 型糖尿病患者。在活动前,除了 1 人之外,所有人都适应了酮体。所有 8 名参与者均完成了项目,无身体损伤或糖尿病控制问题。长时间禁食既不会导致饥饿,也不会对情绪产生负面影响,实际上,大多数人的情绪都有所增强。所有适应酮体的人在 5 天内都显示出在消耗脂肪储存,并且所有人都处于营养性酮症状态。在 1 型糖尿病中,酮体与非糖尿病患者的酮体处于相同范围,胰岛素用量明显减少,血糖控制接近生理状态:营养性酮症不是糖尿病酮症酸中毒的危险因素;在适应酮体的人群中,不需要消耗糖来提供能量,他们可以完成长达 100 英里的运动;注射胰岛素的人除非要抢救低血糖发作,否则不一定需要摄入碳水化合物。
本项目的发现应该为那些希望为 1 型糖尿病患者提供生酮生活方式选择的临床医生提供信心。它们还证实,脂肪储存可用于有氧呼吸,而不会对身体或精神功能产生明显的负面影响。