Department of Bussiness Administration & Tourism, Hellenic Mediterranean University, Crete, Greece.
School of Social Sciences, Hellenic Open University, Patras, Greece.
J Adv Nurs. 2022 Feb;78(2):434-445. doi: 10.1111/jan.14994. Epub 2021 Aug 1.
To examine the associations between nurse work environment with nurses' silence about patient safety and the mediating effects of professional discrimination experienced by nurses.
Multicentre cross-sectional study.
Between January and April 2019, 607 nurses and nursing assistants from seven hospitals in Greece assessed their clinical environment using the 'Practice Environment Scale of the Nursing Work Index Revised-PES-NWIR', and the silence about patient safety. The 'Experiences of Discrimination Index' was adapted to specifically address experienced discrimination based on the nursing profession. The PROCESS macros for SPSS were used to examine the above associations.
Better nurse practice environment, with the exception of 'staffing and resource adequacy' dimension, was directly associated with less experienced professional discrimination, and directly and indirectly associated with less silence about patient safety, through the mediating role of professional discrimination experienced by nurses.
Silence about patient safety is dependent on the clinical work environment and may be a response of nurses to discrimination in the work context. Both an improvement in the nurse work environment and a decrease in professional discrimination would minimize silence about patient safety.
On many occasions, nurses are directly or indirectly discouraged from voicing their concerns about patient safety or are ignored when they do, leading to employee silence and decreasing the standard of care (Alingh et al., BMJ Quality & Safety, 2019, 28, 39; Pope, Journal of Change Management, 2019, 19, 45). Nurses' work-related determinants for silence are not clearly understood in the patient safety context. A favourably evaluated nurse practice environment is associated with less experienced professional discrimination and less silence about patient safety. To minimize silence about patient safety, both the nurse work environment and the experienced professional discrimination should be taken into consideration by nurse and healthcare managers.
探讨护士工作环境与护士对患者安全保持沉默之间的关系,并检验护士所经历的职业歧视的中介作用。
多中心横断面研究。
2019 年 1 月至 4 月,来自希腊 7 家医院的 607 名护士和护理助理使用“护理工作指数修订版实践环境量表(PES-NWIR)”评估其临床环境,并评估对患者安全保持沉默的情况。专门针对基于护理职业的歧视,改编了“歧视经历指数”。使用 SPSS 的 PROCESS 宏检验上述关联。
除“人员配备和资源充足”维度外,更好的护士实践环境与较少的职业歧视经历直接相关,并通过护士所经历的职业歧视的中介作用,与较少的对患者安全保持沉默直接和间接相关。
对患者安全的沉默取决于临床工作环境,可能是护士对工作环境中歧视的反应。改善护士工作环境和减少职业歧视将最大限度地减少对患者安全的沉默。
在许多情况下,护士会因对患者安全表示关注而受到直接或间接的劝阻,或者他们的意见被忽视,导致员工保持沉默,降低护理标准(Alingh 等人,BMJ Quality & Safety,2019,28,39;Pope,Journal of Change Management,2019,19,45)。在患者安全背景下,护士对工作相关沉默的决定因素尚不清楚。有利的护士实践环境评估与较少的职业歧视经历和较少的对患者安全的沉默有关。为了最大限度地减少对患者安全的沉默,护士和医疗保健管理人员应同时考虑护士的工作环境和所经历的职业歧视。