Department of Radiology and Imaging Sciences, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia.
Department of Radiology and Imaging Sciences, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia.
J Am Coll Radiol. 2021 Nov;18(11):1532-1539. doi: 10.1016/j.jacr.2021.07.006. Epub 2021 Jul 31.
PURPOSE: Clinical practice guidelines intended to reduce unnecessary cervical spine imaging have yielded mixed results. We aimed to assess evolving emergency department (ED) cervical spine imaging utilization in patients with trauma by injury severity. METHODS: Using 2009 to 2018 IBM MarketScan Commercial Databases, we identified ED trauma encounters, associated cervical spine imaging, and related diagnosis codes. We classified encounters by injury severity (minor, intermediate, major) using an International Classification of Disease code-derived Injury Severity Score algorithm and studied evolving imaging utilization using multivariable Poisson regression models. RESULTS: Of all 11,346,684 ED visits for trauma, 7,753,914 (68.3%), 3,524,250 (31.1%), and 68,520 (0.6%) involved minor, intermediate, and major injuries, respectively. Overall cervical spine imaging increased 5.7% annually (incidence rate ratio [IRR] 1.057, P < .001) with radiography decreasing 2.7% annually (IRR 0.973, P < .001) and CT increasing 10.5% annually (IRR 1.105, P < .001). Radiography utilization remained unchanged for minor injuries (IRR 0.994, P = .14) but decreased for intermediate (IRR 0.928 versus minor, P < .001) and major (IRR 0.931 versus minor, P < .001) injuries. Increases in CT utilization were greatest for minor injuries (IRR 1.109, P < .001) with smaller increases in intermediate (IRR 0.960 versus minor, P < .001) and major (IRR 0.987 versus minor, P = .022) injuries. CONCLUSIONS: Recent increases in cervical spine imaging in commercially insured patients with trauma seen in the ED have been largely related to increases in CT for patients with only minor injuries, in whom imaging utilization has been historically low. Further study is necessary to assess appropriateness, implications on costs and population radiation dose, and factors influencing ordering decision making.
目的:旨在减少不必要的颈椎影像学检查的临床实践指南取得了喜忧参半的结果。我们旨在评估创伤患者颈椎影像学检查在急诊科(ED)的利用情况随损伤严重程度的变化。
方法:利用 2009 年至 2018 年 IBM MarketScan 商业数据库,我们确定了 ED 创伤患者的就诊情况、相关颈椎影像学检查和相关诊断代码。我们使用国际疾病分类代码衍生的损伤严重程度评分算法将就诊情况分为轻度、中度和重度损伤,并使用多变量泊松回归模型研究了不断变化的影像学应用情况。
结果:在所有 11346684 例 ED 创伤就诊中,分别有 68.3%(7753914 例)、31.1%(3524250 例)和 0.6%(68520 例)为轻度、中度和重度损伤。整体颈椎影像学检查每年增加 5.7%(发病率比 [IRR] 1.057,P <.001),射线照相术每年减少 2.7%(IRR 0.973,P <.001),CT 每年增加 10.5%(IRR 1.105,P <.001)。轻度损伤的射线照相术使用率保持不变(IRR 0.994,P =.14),但中度(IRR 0.928 与轻度,P <.001)和重度(IRR 0.931 与轻度,P <.001)损伤的射线照相术使用率下降。CT 使用率的增加在轻度损伤中最大(IRR 1.109,P <.001),中度损伤(IRR 0.960 与轻度,P <.001)和重度损伤(IRR 0.987 与轻度,P =.022)的增加较小。
结论:最近在 ED 就诊的商业保险创伤患者中,颈椎影像学检查的增加主要与 CT 检查的增加有关,而 CT 检查在只有轻度损伤的患者中一直使用率较低。需要进一步研究以评估适当性、对成本和人群辐射剂量的影响以及影响订单决策的因素。
J Am Coll Radiol. 2013-9-11
J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2024-9-1
West J Emerg Med. 2023-9