Kansas City Heart Rhythm Institute, Overland Park, Kansas.
Division of Cardiology, Cardiac Arrhythmia Service, Loma Linda University Health, Loma Linda, California.
Heart Rhythm. 2022 Jan;19(1):30-38. doi: 10.1016/j.hrthm.2021.07.010. Epub 2021 Jul 30.
Medical treatment of inappropriate sinus tachycardia (IST) remains suboptimal. Radiofrequency sinus node (RF-SN) ablation has poor success and higher complication rates.
We aimed to compare clinical outcomes of the novel SN sparing hybrid ablation technique with those of RF-SN modification for IST management.
This is a multicenter prospective registry comparing the SN sparing hybrid ablation strategy with RF-SN modification. The hybrid procedure was performed using an RF bipolar clamp, isolating superior vena cava/inferior vena cava with the creation of a lateral line across the crista terminalis while sparing the SN region (identified by endocardial 3-dimensional mapping). RF-SN modification was performed by endocardial and/or epicardial mapping and ablation at the site of earliest atrial activation.
Of the 100 patients (hybrid ablation group, n = 50; RF-SN group, n = 50), 82% were women, and the mean age was 22.8 years. Normal sinus rhythm and rate were restored in all patients in the hybrid group (vs 84% in the RF-SN group; P = .006). Hybrid ablation was associated with significantly better improvement in mean daily heart rate and peak 6-minute walk heart rate compared with RF-SN ablation. The RF-SN group had a significantly higher rate of redo procedures (100% vs 8%; P < .001), phrenic nerve injury (14% vs 0%; P = .012), lower acute pericarditis (48% vs 92%; P < .0001), permanent pacemaker implantation (50% vs 4%; P < .0001) than did the hybrid ablation group.
The novel sinus node sparing hybrid ablation procedure appears to be more efficacious and safer in patients with symptomatic drug-resistant IST with long-term durability than RF-SN ablation.
不适当窦速(IST)的医学治疗仍不尽人意。射频窦房结(RF-SN)消融术成功率低,并发症发生率高。
比较新型窦房结保留杂交消融技术与 RF-SN 改良治疗 IST 的临床效果。
这是一项多中心前瞻性研究,比较了窦房结保留杂交消融策略与 RF-SN 改良的效果。杂交术采用 RF 双极夹进行,在创建横跨终嵴的侧线的同时,隔离上腔静脉/下腔静脉,同时保留窦房结区域(通过心内膜 3 维标测识别)。RF-SN 改良通过心内膜和/或心外膜标测和消融最早心房激活部位进行。
在 100 例患者(杂交消融组 n = 50;RF-SN 组 n = 50)中,82%为女性,平均年龄为 22.8 岁。所有患者在杂交组中均恢复正常窦性节律和心率(与 RF-SN 组的 84%相比;P =.006)。与 RF-SN 消融相比,杂交消融显著改善平均日常心率和 6 分钟步行峰值心率。RF-SN 组行再次手术的比例明显更高(100%比 8%;P <.001),膈神经损伤的比例(14%比 0%;P =.012)、急性心包炎的比例(48%比 92%;P <.0001)、永久性起搏器植入的比例(50%比 4%;P <.0001)均明显低于杂交消融组。
与 RF-SN 消融相比,新型窦房结保留杂交消融术在药物治疗无效的有症状 IST 患者中似乎更有效、更安全,且具有长期耐久性。