Mishani Siamak, Belhoul-Fakir Hanane, Lagat Chris, Jansen Shirley, Evans Brian, Lawrence-Brown Michael
WA School of Mines: MECE, Faculty of Science & Engineering, Curtin University, Kensington, WA, Australia.
School of Public Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, Curtin University, Nedlands, WA, Australia.
Quant Imaging Med Surg. 2021 Aug;11(8):3494-3505. doi: 10.21037/qims-20-614.
There is a correlation between the sites of atheroma development and stress points in the arterial system. Generally, pulse pressure results in stresses acting on the vascular vessel, including longitudinal stress, radial or normal stress, tangential stress or hoop stress and shear stress. This paper explores the relationship between arterial wall shear stress and pulsatile blood pressure with the aim of furthering the understanding of atherogenesis and plaque progression.
We computed the magnitude of the shear stresses within the carotid bifurcation geometry of a patient and calculated the increase in shear stress levels that would occur when the blood pressure and pulse pressures rise during exertion. We also determined in which layer of the artery wall the maximum shear stress is located, and computed the shear stress at different levels within the media. We used the theory of laminate analysis, (Classical Laminate Plate Theory), to analyse the stress distribution on the carotid artery wall. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) analysis was used on anatomy based on a CT angiogram of the carotid bifurcation of a patient with a 90% stenosis on the right side and 10% on the left. The pulsatile non-Newtonian blood flow with a resting blood pressure of 120/80 mmHg and an exertion pressure of 200/100 mmHg was simulated and the resultant forces were transferred to an ANSYS Composite PrepPost (ACP) model for wall shear stress analysis. A multilayer elastic, anisotropic, and inhomogeneous arterial wall (intima, internal elastic lamina, media, external elastic lamina, and adventitial layers) was modelled and the shear stress magnitudes and change over time between the layers was calculated.
Shear stress in the individual composite layers is far greater than that acting on the endothelium (less than 5 Pa). At rest, the maximum variation of shear stress in the arterial wall occurs in the intima (138 Pa) and adventitia (135 Pa). The medial layer has the lowest variation of shear stress. Under severe exertion, the maximum shear stress magnitude in the intimal layer and the adjacent medial layer is near the ultimate stress level. The maximum/minimum shear stress ratios during the cardiac cycle vary most widely in the innermost part of the media, adjacent to the intima, with a four-fold ratio increase. This compares with a less than two-fold increase in all the other layers including the intima and adventitia, making the inner media the most vulnerable layer to mechanical injury.
This study showed that the magnitude of exertion-induced shear stress approaches the ultimate stress limit in the intima and the immediate adjacent medial layer. The variation in stress is maximal in the inner layer of the media. These findings correlate the site of atheroma development with the most vulnerable site for injury in the media and emphasise the impact of pulse pressure. Further biological studies are required to ascertain whether this leads to injury that initiates atheroma that then precipitates an injury/healing cycle.
动脉粥样硬化发展部位与动脉系统中的应力点之间存在相关性。一般来说,脉压会导致作用于血管的应力,包括纵向应力、径向或法向应力、切向应力或环向应力以及剪切应力。本文探讨动脉壁剪切应力与脉动血压之间的关系,旨在进一步了解动脉粥样硬化的发生和斑块进展。
我们计算了一名患者颈动脉分叉几何结构内的剪切应力大小,并计算了运动时血压和脉压升高时剪切应力水平的增加。我们还确定了动脉壁最大剪切应力所在的层,并计算了中膜内不同水平的剪切应力。我们使用层合分析理论(经典层合板理论)来分析颈动脉壁上的应力分布。对一名右侧狭窄90%、左侧狭窄10%的患者的颈动脉分叉CT血管造影所基于的解剖结构进行了计算流体动力学(CFD)分析。模拟了静息血压为120/80 mmHg、运动压力为200/100 mmHg时的脉动非牛顿血流,并将合力传递到ANSYS Composite PrepPost(ACP)模型进行壁面剪切应力分析。建立了多层弹性、各向异性和非均匀的动脉壁模型(内膜、内弹性膜、中膜、外弹性膜和外膜层),并计算了各层之间的剪切应力大小及其随时间的变化。
单个复合层中的剪切应力远大于作用于内皮的剪切应力(小于5 Pa)。静息时,动脉壁剪切应力的最大变化发生在内膜(138 Pa)和外膜(135 Pa)。中膜层的剪切应力变化最小。在剧烈运动时,内膜层和相邻中膜层的最大剪切应力大小接近极限应力水平。心动周期中的最大/最小剪切应力比在中膜最内层、与内膜相邻处变化最广泛,增加了四倍。相比之下,包括内膜和外膜在内的所有其他层的增加不到两倍,使得中膜内层成为最易受机械损伤的层。
本研究表明,运动诱导的剪切应力大小接近内膜和紧邻的中膜层的极限应力极限。应力变化在中膜内层最大。这些发现将动脉粥样硬化发展部位与中膜最易受伤部位相关联,并强调了脉压的影响。需要进一步的生物学研究来确定这是否会导致引发动脉粥样硬化的损伤,进而引发损伤/愈合循环。