Humber River Hospital, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Institute of Health Policy, Management and Evaluation, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
BMC Med Inform Decis Mak. 2021 Aug 5;21(1):235. doi: 10.1186/s12911-021-01598-4.
Home blood pressure measurements have equal or even greater predictive value than clinic blood pressure measurements regarding cardiovascular outcomes. With advances in home blood pressure monitors, we face an imminent flood of home measurements, but current electronic health record systems lack the functionality to allow us to use this data to its fullest. We designed a data visualization display for blood pressure measurements to be used for shared decision making around hypertension.
We used an iterative, rapid-prototyping, user-centred design approach to determine the most appropriate designs for this data display. We relied on visual cognition and human factors principles when designing our display. Feedback was provided by expert members of our multidisciplinary research team and through a series of end-user focus groups, comprised of either hypertensive patients or their healthcare providers required from eight academic, community-based practices in the Midwest of the United States.
A total of 40 participants were recruited to participate in patient (N = 16) and provider (N = 24) focus groups. We describe the conceptualization and development of data display for shared decision making around hypertension. We designed and received feedback from both patients and healthcare providers on a number of design elements that were reported to be helpful in understanding blood pressure measurements.
We developed a data display for substantial amounts of blood pressure measurements that is both simple to understand for patients, but powerful enough to inform clinical decision making. The display used a line graph format for ease of understanding, a LOWESS function for smoothing data to reduce the weight users placed on outlier measurements, colored goal range bands to allow users to quickly determine if measurements were in range, a medication timeline to help link recorded blood pressure measurements with the medications a patient was taking. A data display such as this, specifically designed to encourage shared decision making between hypertensive patients and their healthcare providers, could help us overcome the clinical inertia that often results in a lack of treatment intensification, leading to better care for the 35 million Americans with uncontrolled hypertension.
家庭血压测量在预测心血管结局方面与诊所血压测量具有同等甚至更大的价值。随着家庭血压监测仪的进步,我们即将面临大量的家庭测量数据,但当前的电子健康记录系统缺乏充分利用这些数据的功能。我们设计了一种血压测量数据可视化显示,用于围绕高血压进行共享决策。
我们采用迭代、快速原型、以用户为中心的设计方法,确定最适合这种数据显示的设计。在设计我们的显示器时,我们依赖于视觉认知和人类因素原则。我们的多学科研究团队的专家成员以及来自美国中西部 8 个学术性、社区性实践的一系列患者和医疗服务提供者焦点小组提供了反馈。
共有 40 名参与者被招募参加患者(N=16)和提供者(N=24)焦点小组。我们描述了高血压共享决策的概念化和数据显示的开发。我们设计了一些设计元素,并从患者和医疗服务提供者那里获得了反馈,这些元素被报告有助于理解血压测量值。
我们开发了一种用于大量血压测量值的数据显示,既易于患者理解,又足以为临床决策提供信息。该显示器使用线图格式,便于理解,使用 LOWESS 函数对数据进行平滑处理,以减少用户对异常值测量的重视,使用彩色目标范围带允许用户快速确定测量值是否在范围内,使用药物时间轴帮助将记录的血压测量值与患者正在服用的药物联系起来。这种专门设计用于鼓励高血压患者及其医疗服务提供者之间共享决策的数据显示,可以帮助我们克服导致治疗强化不足的临床惯性,从而为 3500 万未控制高血压的美国人提供更好的护理。