Essue Beverley M, Kapiriri Lydia
Centre for Health Economics and Policy Analysis, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada.
Department of Health, Aging and Society, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada.
Health Syst (Basingstoke). 2020 May 18;10(3):222-237. doi: 10.1080/20476965.2020.1758596. eCollection 2021.
Health systems are critical to the realisation of Universal Health Coverage. There has been insufficient attention to the evaluation of priority setting for health system strengthening within low income countries, including evaluation of the local capacity to implement priorities. This study evaluated the extent to which health system strengthening was prioritized in Uganda. The Kapiriri & Martin framework was used to evaluate health system priority setting from 2005-2015. A document analysis was triangulated with interview data (n = 67) from global, national and subnational stakeholders and analysed using content analysis. Health system strengthening was perceived to be circumvented by a lack of resources as well as influential actors with disease focused, rather than system-oriented, interests. There were defined processes with explicit criteria for identifying priorities and evidence was highly valued. But sub-optimal transparency and weak accountability often compromised the integrity of priority setting and contributed to stalling progress on health system strengthening and achieving health system outcomes. The strengths in the current planning processes should be harnessed. In addition, a systematic approach to priority setting, potentially through the establishment of an independent body, and stronger oversight mechanisms, would strengthen health system planning in this setting.
卫生系统对于实现全民健康覆盖至关重要。低收入国家对卫生系统强化的优先事项设定评估关注不足,包括对当地实施优先事项能力的评估。本研究评估了乌干达在多大程度上对卫生系统强化进行了优先排序。使用卡皮里里和马丁框架评估了2005年至2015年期间卫生系统的优先事项设定。通过对来自全球、国家和地方各级利益相关者的访谈数据(n = 67)进行三角互证,并采用内容分析法对一份文件分析进行补充。由于缺乏资源以及有影响力的行为者关注疾病而非系统导向的利益,卫生系统强化被认为受到了阻碍。确定优先事项有明确的流程和标准,证据受到高度重视。但透明度欠佳和问责不力常常损害了优先事项设定的公正性,导致卫生系统强化工作停滞不前,无法实现卫生系统成果。应利用当前规划流程中的优势。此外,通过建立独立机构和加强监督机制,采取系统的优先事项设定方法,将加强这一背景下的卫生系统规划。