Mehra Kamna, Hawke Lisa D, Watson Priya, Sheikhan Natasha Y, Leroux Elisabeth, Henderson Joanna
Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, Toronto, Ontario.
Department of Psychiatry, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario.
J Can Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2021 Aug;30(3):165-176. Epub 2021 Aug 1.
Psychotherapy is the recommended first line of treatment for depression among youth; however, few youth seek professional support. This study compares barriers and facilitators to seeking psychotherapy among both youth who have and have not seen a psychotherapist. The study further explores reasons youth discontinue psychotherapy.
A concurrent mixed methods study design was used. Eligible participants completed a survey (N=104) and a subset of participants completed a semi-structured interview (N=60). The survey and interview data were analyzed concurrently using a triangulation design.
Surveys were conducted among youth who had experienced psychotherapy (N=53) and youth who had not (N=51). The majority of participants were female. Common reasons for not seeking psychotherapy included wanting to handle their problems on their own (87.6%), thinking their problems would improve on its own (87.6%), and not knowing who to see (74.3%). Several barriers were common across the two groups, including stigma, concerns about the therapeutic relationship, and a preference for self-management. Common facilitators included improving coping skills and addressing functional impairment. There was some overlap between the barriers to seeking psychotherapy and the reasons for discontinuing, although aging out of youth-oriented service also constituted a termination factor.
: As this study highlights the multiple factors that influence youth's psychotherapy-seeking behavior, a widespread, multi-level approach is needed to address barriers and facilitators at the individual level, but also at the community, policy, and organizational levels. Strategies such as increasing service availability and quality are needed to increase service seeking and improve retention.
心理治疗是青少年抑郁症推荐的一线治疗方法;然而,很少有青少年寻求专业帮助。本研究比较了看过心理治疗师和未看过心理治疗师的青少年在寻求心理治疗方面的障碍和促进因素。该研究进一步探讨了青少年停止心理治疗的原因。
采用同步混合方法研究设计。符合条件的参与者完成了一项调查(N = 104),一部分参与者完成了半结构化访谈(N = 60)。使用三角测量设计对调查和访谈数据进行同步分析。
对接受过心理治疗的青少年(N = 53)和未接受过心理治疗的青少年(N = 51)进行了调查。大多数参与者为女性。不寻求心理治疗的常见原因包括想自己解决问题(87.6%)、认为问题会自行改善(87.6%)以及不知道该找谁(74.3%)。两组中都存在一些常见障碍,包括耻辱感、对治疗关系的担忧以及对自我管理的偏好。常见的促进因素包括提高应对技能和解决功能障碍。寻求心理治疗的障碍和停止治疗的原因之间存在一些重叠,尽管超过青少年服务年龄也构成了终止治疗的一个因素。
由于本研究强调了影响青少年寻求心理治疗行为的多种因素,需要一种广泛的、多层次的方法来解决个体层面以及社区、政策和组织层面的障碍和促进因素。需要采取增加服务可及性和质量等策略来增加寻求服务的人数并提高留存率。