Department of Health, Medicine and Caring Sciences, Pain and Rehabilitation Center, Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden.
Pain and Rehabilitation Center, University Hospital, Linköping, Sweden.
Scand J Pain. 2020 Dec 10;21(2):256-265. doi: 10.1515/sjpain-2020-0067. Print 2021 Apr 27.
Patients with head and neck cancer (HNC) experience serious pain related to tumour, surgery, chemotherapy, and radiotherapy treatment (RT). Oral mucositis, a painful complication of RT, may require opioid analgesics to control pain.This longitudinal study, during RT but also four weeks post-RT, examines the relationships between oral mucositis, pain, and opioid doses in in HNC patients. The aim was to evaluate the clinical effectiveness of an opioid treatment strategy.
Sixty-three patients with HNC undergoing radiotherapy answered self-reported questionnaires on pain intensity on a 0-10 numerical rating scale (NRS) three times a week. Oral mucositis signs were evaluated using the WHO mucositis index score, ranging from 0 (normal) to 4 (severe), and pharmacological treatment with opioids was registered prospectively once a week. All data were related to given radiation dose, and all outcome measures at each time point therefore relate to the same radiation dose (i.e., not to when the patient was included in the study).
Opioids were used by 78% of the patients. Most of the patients experienced only mild pain (NRS 0-4), although the majority developed mucositis grade 2-4 according to WHO mucositis index. Function-related pain intensity and opioid doses were highest during the sixth week of RT, with 3.67 (0-9) in NRS and 84 (0-430) mg oral morphine equivalents per day (median, range). At that same time point, significant positive correlations were found between the grade of mucositis and pain intensities. Patients with mucositis grade 2-4 were investigated further; in this subgroup, we found that opioid doses did not differ between patients with mild pain and patients with moderate to severe pain. Our multivariate data analysis defined a cluster of patients characterized by the presence of mucositis, cancer site in pharynx, concomitant chemotherapy, and the absence of surgery.
In HNC patients who were followed closely by pain care personnel during and after RT, pain was often satisfactorily alleviated with a structured use of opioids, including stepwise increases of fentanyl patches and oral morphine as needed. However, some patients with oral mucositis grade 2-4 experienced severe pain. Strong opioids, i.e. the third step of the WHO pain ladder, remain the mainstay of analgesic therapy in treating moderate to severe cancer-related pain, including patients with HNC. This real-life study indicates that RT-related pain is not a fatality. A proactive stance, monitoring these patients closely and regularly, is probably crucial in order to achieve good treatment results. Further studies are needed to develop better pain treatment strategies for those patients who develop severe oral mucositis-related pain despite intensive opioid treatment.
头颈部癌症(HNC)患者经历与肿瘤、手术、化疗和放射治疗(RT)相关的严重疼痛。口腔黏膜炎是 RT 的一种疼痛并发症,可能需要阿片类镇痛药来控制疼痛。本纵向研究在 RT 期间以及 RT 后四周,检查了 HNC 患者口腔黏膜炎、疼痛和阿片类药物剂量之间的关系。目的是评估阿片类药物治疗策略的临床效果。
63 名接受放疗的 HNC 患者每周三次使用 0-10 数字评分量表(NRS)自我报告疼痛强度问卷。口腔黏膜炎的体征使用世界卫生组织(WHO)黏膜炎指数评分进行评估,范围为 0(正常)至 4(严重),并每周前瞻性记录一次阿片类药物的药理学治疗。所有数据均与给予的辐射剂量相关,因此所有时点的所有结果测量值均与相同的辐射剂量相关(即与患者入组时间无关)。
78%的患者使用了阿片类药物。大多数患者仅经历轻度疼痛(NRS 0-4),尽管大多数患者根据 WHO 黏膜炎指数发展为 2-4 级黏膜炎。功能相关的疼痛强度和阿片类药物剂量在 RT 的第六周最高,NRS 为 3.67(0-9),每日口服吗啡当量 84(0-430)mg(中位数,范围)。在同一时间点,发现黏膜炎程度与疼痛强度之间存在显著的正相关。对 2-4 级黏膜炎的患者进行了进一步研究;在这个亚组中,我们发现轻度疼痛和中度至重度疼痛患者的阿片类药物剂量没有差异。我们的多变量数据分析定义了一组以黏膜炎、咽癌部位、同期化疗和无手术为特征的患者群。
在接受放射治疗期间和之后接受疼痛护理人员密切监测的 HNC 患者中,疼痛通常可以通过阿片类药物的合理使用得到满意缓解,包括按需逐步增加芬太尼贴片和口服吗啡。然而,一些 2-4 级黏膜炎的患者仍经历严重疼痛。强阿片类药物,即世界卫生组织疼痛阶梯的第三阶梯,仍然是治疗中度至重度癌症相关疼痛的主要药物,包括 HNC 患者。这项真实世界的研究表明,RT 相关疼痛并不是致命的。积极主动的态度,定期密切监测这些患者,可能是获得良好治疗效果的关键。需要进一步研究来为那些尽管接受了强化阿片类药物治疗但仍出现严重口腔黏膜炎相关疼痛的患者开发更好的疼痛治疗策略。