Gaughan Theresa C L S, Boe Shaun G
Laboratory for Brain Recovery and Function, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
School of Physiotherapy, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
J Neuropsychol. 2022 Mar;16(1):54-74. doi: 10.1111/jnp.12261. Epub 2021 Aug 16.
The recovery of upper-limb impairment and dysfunction post-stroke is often incomplete owing to the limited time in therapy focused on upper-limb recovery and the severity of the impairment. In these cases, motor imagery (MI) may be used as a precursor to physical therapies to initiate rehabilitation early on when it would be otherwise impossible to engage in therapy, as well as to increase the dose of therapy when MI is used in adjunct to physical therapy. While previous reviews have shown MI to be effective as a therapeutic option, disparity in findings exists, with some studies suggesting MI is not an effective treatment for post-stroke impairment and dysfunction. One factor contributing to these findings is inconsistency in the dose of MI applied. To explore the relationship between MI dose and recovery, a scoping review of MI literature as a treatment for adult survivors of stroke with chronic upper-limb motor deficit was performed. Embase, Medline and CINHAL databases were searched for articles related to MI and stroke. Following a two-phase review process, 21 papers were included, and data related to treatment dose and measures of impairment and function were extracted. Effect sizes were calculated to investigate the effect of dosage on motor recovery. Findings showed a high degree of variability in dosage regimens across studies, with no clear pattern for the effect of dose on outcome. The present review highlights the gaps in MI literature, including variables that contribute to the dose-response relationship, that future studies should consider when implementing MI.
由于专注于上肢恢复的治疗时间有限以及损伤的严重程度,中风后上肢损伤和功能障碍的恢复往往不完全。在这些情况下,运动想象(MI)可作为物理治疗的前奏,以便在无法进行治疗时尽早启动康复治疗,以及在将运动想象与物理治疗结合使用时增加治疗剂量。虽然先前的综述表明运动想象作为一种治疗选择是有效的,但研究结果存在差异,一些研究表明运动想象对中风后的损伤和功能障碍并非有效治疗方法。导致这些结果的一个因素是运动想象应用剂量的不一致。为了探讨运动想象剂量与恢复之间的关系,对作为慢性上肢运动缺陷中风成年幸存者治疗方法的运动想象文献进行了范围综述。在Embase、Medline和CINHAL数据库中搜索了与运动想象和中风相关的文章。经过两阶段的综述过程,纳入了21篇论文,并提取了与治疗剂量以及损伤和功能测量相关的数据。计算效应大小以研究剂量对运动恢复的影响。研究结果表明,各研究的剂量方案存在高度变异性,剂量对结果的影响没有明确模式。本综述强调了运动想象文献中的空白,包括影响剂量反应关系的变量,未来研究在实施运动想象时应予以考虑。