Department of Sociology, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
Can Rev Sociol. 2021 Aug;58(3):372-398. doi: 10.1111/cars.12348.
Young adults born at the end of the 20th century attend colleges and universities at much higher rates than did previous generations, which might give the impression of greater upward educational mobility and in turn, greater class mobility. This impression occurs, however, only because of structural expansion of the Canadian education system. In contrast to structural change, exchange mobility highlights the linkage between one's social origins and destinations. This speaks more directly to questions of equality of educational opportunity and social fairness. Greater fairness or social progress occurs when, over time, destinations become less contingent on origins. We examine intergenerational exchange mobility in Canada by investigating how, if at all, the linkage between parents' and their children's education has changed over the past century. We construct a longitudinal dataset covering the 20th century by merging fifteen cross-sectional surveys from Statistics Canada's General Social Survey (GSS) between 1986 and 2014. Comparing across synthetic birth cohorts we focus on transition probabilities, odds ratios, and logistic regression estimates to measure change. We contribute to a growing gap in the Canadian literature since social mobility has been largely neglected by sociologists as of late. We compare our results to recent findings of economists who examine intergenerational income mobility, another indicator of class mobility. Consistent with earlier sociological and economic research, our results show that despite the tremendous expansion of Canada's education systems, intergenerational exchange mobility for both women and men has been stagnant in Canada over the past century.
20 世纪末出生的年轻人上大学的比例远远高于前几代人,这可能给人留下了向上的教育流动性更大的印象,进而带来更大的阶级流动性。然而,这种印象仅仅是因为加拿大教育系统的结构性扩张。与结构性变化相反,交换流动性突出了一个人社会出身和目的地之间的联系。这更直接地涉及到教育机会平等和社会公平的问题。随着时间的推移,当目的地不再取决于出身时,就会出现更大的公平或社会进步。我们通过调查父母和子女的教育之间的联系在过去一个世纪中是否发生了变化,来研究加拿大代际交换流动性。我们通过合并加拿大统计局的综合社会调查(GSS)在 1986 年至 2014 年之间的 15 项横断面调查,构建了一个涵盖整个 20 世纪的纵向数据集。通过比较综合出生队列,我们关注转移概率、优势比和逻辑回归估计值,以衡量变化。我们对加拿大文献中的一个日益扩大的差距做出了贡献,因为社会流动性在最近被社会学家忽视了。我们将我们的结果与经济学家最近对代际收入流动性的研究进行了比较,代际收入流动性是阶级流动性的另一个指标。与早期的社会学和经济学研究一致,我们的结果表明,尽管加拿大教育系统经历了巨大的扩张,但在过去一个世纪中,加拿大女性和男性的代际交换流动性一直停滞不前。