Pritzker School of Medicine, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
Section of Hematology/Oncology, Department of Medicine, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
J Adolesc Young Adult Oncol. 2022 Jun;11(3):284-289. doi: 10.1089/jayao.2021.0096. Epub 2021 Aug 17.
We sought to understand clinician-level barriers to providing HPV vaccination to survivors of childhood and young adult cancers (CYACs). We conducted 30-minute qualitative interviews with primary care and specialty clinicians who care for survivors of CYACs at our academic medical center. Blinded reviewers analyzed transcripts and used an inductive approach to identify barriers to vaccination in this population. We conducted 24 interviews ( = 11 primary care clinicians, = 13 oncology clinicians). Thematic analysis revealed that primary care clinicians are universally viewed as holding ultimate responsibility for human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination among survivors of CYACs. Both primary care and oncology clinicians believed vague, inconsistent HPV guidelines engendered uncertainty toward HPV vaccination's role and timing following completion of CYAC therapies. As such, compared with other vaccines, the HPV vaccination is not as consistently offered to survivors. Respondents identified direct guidance from oncologists to primary care clinicians and to patients as a potential strategy for improving HPV vaccination rates in this population. Finally, oncology clinicians frequently deprioritize the issue of preventing second, noniatrogenic cancers and consequently miss opportunities to discuss vaccination's merits with their patients. Despite not holding ultimate responsibility for vaccination, oncology clinicians have an opportunity to play an important role in ensuring access and overcoming hesitancy among survivors of CYACs. Developing clearer and more collaborative guidelines, helping to integrate vaccination into institutional electronic health record protocols, offering direct guidance to primary care colleagues, and participating in conversations with survivors of CYACs may help improve vaccination rates.
我们试图了解临床医生层面在为儿童期和青年期癌症幸存者(CYACs)提供 HPV 疫苗接种方面的障碍。我们对在我们的学术医疗中心照顾 CYAC 幸存者的初级保健和专科临床医生进行了 30 分钟的定性访谈。盲审员分析了转录本,并使用归纳方法确定了该人群中疫苗接种的障碍。我们进行了 24 次访谈( = 11 名初级保健临床医生, = 13 名肿瘤学临床医生)。主题分析显示,初级保健临床医生普遍被认为对 CYAC 幸存者的 HPV 疫苗接种负有最终责任。初级保健和肿瘤学临床医生都认为,HPV 指南模糊且不一致,导致他们对 CYAC 治疗完成后 HPV 疫苗接种的作用和时机存在不确定性。因此,与其他疫苗相比,HPV 疫苗接种在幸存者中并没有得到一致的提供。受访者认为,向初级保健临床医生和患者提供肿瘤学家的直接指导是提高该人群 HPV 疫苗接种率的潜在策略。最后,肿瘤学临床医生经常将预防第二、非医源性癌症的问题放在次要地位,从而错失了与患者讨论疫苗接种益处的机会。尽管对疫苗接种没有最终责任,但肿瘤学临床医生有机会在确保 CYAC 幸存者获得疫苗接种和克服其犹豫方面发挥重要作用。制定更清晰和更具协作性的指南,帮助将疫苗接种纳入机构电子健康记录协议,向初级保健同事提供直接指导,并参与与 CYAC 幸存者的对话,可能有助于提高疫苗接种率。