Yang Q, Xue P, Dou W J, Fan X, Song B Q
Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, the First Affiliated Hospital of Air Force Medical University, Xi'an 710032, China.
Zhonghua Shao Shang Za Zhi. 2021 Aug 20;37(8):718-724. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn501120-20210416-00132.
To explore the clinical effects of follicle unit extraction (FUE) transplantation combined with recombinant bovine basic fibroblast growth factor (rb-bFGF) gel and minoxidil tincture in treating secondary cicatricial alopecia (hereinafter referred to as cicatricial alopecia). A retrospective observational study was conducted. According to the different treatment methods, 50 cicatricial alopecia patients who met the inclusion criteria and only underwent FUE transplantation in the First Affiliated Hospital of Air Force Medical University from March 2013 to April 2017 were recruited into FUE alone group (26 males and 24 females, aged (28±13) years), and 50 cicatricial alopecia patients who met the inclusion criteria and underwent FUE transplantation+rb-bFGF gel during 1 to 14 days after surgery+minoxidil tincture during 15 to 180 days after surgery in this hospital from May 2017 to April 2020 were recruited into FUE+rb-bFGF+minoxidil group (32 males and 18 females, aged (27±9) years). Hair loss rates in post surgery month (PSM) 3 and 6, hair survival rates and satisfaction rates of patients in PSM 12, and the adverse effect rates of patients in the 2 groups within PSM 12 were observed and calculated. Data were statistically analyzed with chi-square test, Fisher's exact probability test, and independent sample test. In PSM 3 and 6, the hair loss rates of patients in FUE alone group were significantly higher than those in FUE+rb-bFGF+minoxidil group, respectively (=70.850, 42.610, <0.01). In PSM 12, the hair survival rate of patients in FUE+rb-bFGF+minoxidil group was (91.0±2.8)%, which was significantly higher than (80.9±6.9)% in FUE alone group (=9.665, <0.01). In PSM 12, 25 patients were very satisfied, 12 patients were fairly satisfied, 10 patients were slightly satisfied, 2 patients were not satisfied, and 1 patient was very unsatisfied in FUE alone group; 42 patients were very satisfied, 5 patients were fairly satisfied, and 3 patients were slightly satisfied in FUE+rb-bFGF+minoxidil group. The satisfaction rate of patients in FUE alone group was 74% (37/50), which was significantly lower than 94% (47/50) in FUE+rb-bFGF+minoxidil group (<0.01). Within PSM 12, compared with those in FUE+rb-bFGF+minoxidil group, the incidence rates of folliculitis, abnormal growth direction, and skin necrosis in transplant site were not obviously changed in FUE alone group (>0.05), while the incidence of scar in donor site was significantly higher (<0.05). Compared with FUE transplantation alone, FUE transplantation combined with rb-bFGF and minoxidil can reduce the hair loss rate, improve the hair survival rate and the satisfaction rate of patients with cicatricial alopecia after FUE transplantation, with less adverse effects, thus are good for cicatricial alopecia treatment.
探讨毛囊单位提取(FUE)移植联合重组牛碱性成纤维细胞生长因子(rb-bFGF)凝胶及米诺地尔酊治疗继发性瘢痕性秃发(以下简称瘢痕性秃发)的临床效果。进行一项回顾性观察研究。根据不同治疗方法,选取2013年3月至2017年4月在空军军医大学第一附属医院仅接受FUE移植的50例符合纳入标准的瘢痕性秃发患者纳入单纯FUE组(男26例,女24例,年龄(28±13)岁),选取2017年5月至2020年4月在该院接受FUE移植+术后1至14天使用rb-bFGF凝胶+术后15至180天使用米诺地尔酊的50例符合纳入标准的瘢痕性秃发患者纳入FUE+rb-bFGF+米诺地尔组(男32例,女18例,年龄(27±9)岁)。观察并计算术后3个月(PSM)和6个月的脱发率、PSM 12个月时患者的毛发成活率及满意率,以及两组患者PSM 12个月内的不良反应发生率。采用卡方检验、Fisher确切概率法及独立样本检验进行统计学分析。在PSM 3个月和6个月时,单纯FUE组患者的脱发率分别显著高于FUE+rb-bFGF+米诺地尔组(χ²=70.850,42.610,P<0.01)。在PSM 12个月时,FUE+rb-bFGF+米诺地尔组患者的毛发成活率为(91.0±2.8)%,显著高于单纯FUE组的(80.9±6.9)%(χ²=9.665,P<0.01)。在PSM 12个月时,单纯FUE组中25例患者非常满意,12例患者比较满意,10例患者稍有满意,2例患者不满意,1例患者非常不满意;FUE+rb-bFGF+米诺地尔组中42例患者非常满意,5例患者比较满意,3例患者稍有满意。单纯FUE组患者的满意率为74%(37/50),显著低于FUE+rb-bFGF+米诺地尔组的94%(47/50)(P<0.01)。在PSM 12个月内,与FUE+rb-bFGF+米诺地尔组相比,单纯FUE组移植部位的毛囊炎、生长方向异常及皮肤坏死发生率无明显变化(P>0.05),而供区瘢痕发生率显著更高(P<0.05)。与单纯FUE移植相比,FUE移植联合rb-bFGF及米诺地尔可降低瘢痕性秃发患者FUE移植后的脱发率,提高毛发成活率及满意率,不良反应较少,有利于瘢痕性秃发的治疗。