Knox E G
Department of Social Medicine, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, UK.
Int J Epidemiol. 1987 Dec;16(4):569-78. doi: 10.1093/ije/16.4.569.
The principles of rubella vaccine strategy are reviewed against the background of the current UK programme of vaccinating female adolescents, and the contrasting North American programme of vaccinating young children of both sexes. The effects of using both systems simultaneously are then considered: in particular the question of supplementing the established UK system with child vaccination. Previous computer-simulation and mathematical models predicted the consequences of this policy change with insufficient precision, so an elaborated model is proposed, developed and described. Its special advantages over the simpler model from which it was developed are that it represents the detailed pattern of subsequent temporal change, and allows for the effects of earlier epidemic patterns, of seasonal variations in transmission rates, of earlier vaccine policies and changing levels of implementation. Predictions for the current UK programme, unchanged in principle but converging upon target uptake rates, are compared with the effects of introducing a supplementary policy of vaccinating children. Benefits accrue from supplementary child-uptakes greater than about 50%, but the cost effectiveness is poor. In the absence of a commitment to rubella eradication, and provisions for making vaccination compulsory, it should probably not be undertaken.
本文在英国针对青春期女性的疫苗接种计划以及北美针对男女幼儿的疫苗接种计划这两种不同背景下,对风疹疫苗策略的原则进行了审视。随后探讨了同时采用这两种接种体系的效果,尤其是在现有英国接种体系基础上增加儿童接种的问题。以往的计算机模拟和数学模型对这一政策变化后果的预测不够精确,因此提出、开发并描述了一个更精细的模型。相较于其衍生的简单模型,该模型的特殊优势在于它呈现了后续时间变化的详细模式,并考虑了早期流行模式、传播率的季节性变化、早期疫苗政策以及实施水平变化等因素的影响。将针对当前英国接种计划(原则上不变,但正朝着目标接种率趋近)的预测结果,与引入儿童补充接种政策的效果进行了比较。当儿童补充接种率超过约50%时会有收益,但成本效益较差。在没有根除风疹的承诺以及强制接种规定的情况下,或许不应推行这一政策。