Cuartas Carlos Fernandez, Davis Mellar
Geisinger Medical Center, Danville, PA, USA.
Am J Hosp Palliat Care. 2022 May;39(5):562-569. doi: 10.1177/10499091211038371. Epub 2021 Aug 19.
Antipsychotics and benzodiazepines do not improve delirium. Valproic acid (VPA) has been used recently to treat agitation in delirium.
To review the evidence for VPA in the management of Delirium.
Systematic review. English language, age 19 and above, from 1946 to January 12, 2021.
"Valproic acid", "valproate", "sodium valproate", "delirium", "acute mania with delirium" in PubMed and Ovid.
Studies of VPA used for diagnoses other than delirium.
21 abstracts were identified and 10 studies were included in the review (252 patients): One prospective open label study (n: 7), 2 case series (n: 22), 4 retrospective studies (n: 219) and 3 case reports (n: 4). No randomized controlled trial (RCT) evaluates the effect of VPA in delirium. 237/250 (94.8%) patients were in the ICU. Mean age was 59.7 (27-87). 153/204 (74%) were male. The mean starting dose was 733 mg/day in 148 patients and the mean dose at follow up was 1061 mg/day in 205 patients. CAM ICU was used to diagnose delirium in 6 reviews. Delirium improved in case series in 19/22 patients. Delirium improved in retrospective studies at day 3 compared to day 1. VPA levels were not consistently reported. Hyperammonemia (12-19%) and thrombocytopenia (9-13%) were the most common side effects. No deaths were attributed to VPA.
VPA is being used more frequently for delirium. The evidence is limited to retrospective studies and case series. There is a need for RCT to evaluate the effect of VPA in delirium compared to other alternatives and placebo.
抗精神病药物和苯二氮䓬类药物并不能改善谵妄。丙戊酸(VPA)最近已被用于治疗谵妄中的躁动。
综述丙戊酸在谵妄管理中的证据。
系统评价。纳入1946年至2021年1月12日期间发表的英文文献,研究对象年龄在19岁及以上。
在PubMed和Ovid数据库中检索“丙戊酸”“丙戊酸盐”“丙戊酸钠”“谵妄”“伴有谵妄的急性躁狂”。
丙戊酸用于谵妄以外诊断的研究。
共识别出21篇摘要,10项研究纳入综述(252例患者):1项前瞻性开放标签研究(n = 7)、2个病例系列(n = 22)、4项回顾性研究(n = 219)和3例病例报告(n = 4)。尚无随机对照试验评估丙戊酸对谵妄的疗效。250例患者中有237例(94.8%)在重症监护病房(ICU)。平均年龄为59.7岁(27 - 87岁)。204例患者中有153例(74%)为男性。148例患者的平均起始剂量为733毫克/天,205例患者随访时的平均剂量为1061毫克/天。6项综述中使用CAM-ICU诊断谵妄。病例系列中22例患者有19例谵妄得到改善。回顾性研究中,与第1天相比,第3天谵妄有所改善。丙戊酸水平报告不一致。高氨血症(12% - 19%)和血小板减少症(9% - 13%)是最常见的副作用。无死亡病例归因于丙戊酸。
丙戊酸在谵妄治疗中的应用越来越频繁。证据仅限于回顾性研究和病例系列。需要进行随机对照试验,以评估丙戊酸与其他替代药物及安慰剂相比对谵妄的疗效。