Fujiwara Yasushi, Kotaka Shinji, Ohta Ryo, Arakawa Yasuo, Kadonishi Yutaka, Nishimori Makoto, Manabe Hideki, Adachi Nobuo
Orthopedics and Micro-surgical Spine Center, Hiroshima City Asa Hospital, Hiroshima, Japan.
Medical Engineering Center, Hiroshima City Asa Hospital, Hiroshima, Japan.
Spine Surg Relat Res. 2020 Dec 5;5(4):238-243. doi: 10.22603/ssrr.2020-0144. eCollection 2021.
Surgeons need precise information about motor deterioration risk during surgery for intramedullary spinal cord tumors (IMSCTs). However, the conventional TcMsEP alarm criterion provides limited information with a less than or a more than single alarm criterion without any grades in between, resulting in false-negative and false-positive outcomes. Therefore, we developed a "seven-color TcMsEP grading system" for neuromonitoring to provide more graded information. This study investigates the system's efficacy.
This study included 60 patients that underwent resection surgeries for IMSCTs. TcMsEP outcomes were classified into seven grades: Grade "D-0 Green" includes a wave amplitude decrease of 0%-50% compared with the baseline amplitude. Grade "D-1 Lime" includes a 50%-70% decrease. Grade "D-2 Yellow" includes a 70%-90% decrease. Grade "D-3 Orange" includes a more than 90% decrease with a clearly visible waveform. Grade "D-4 Red" includes a minimal and abnormally shaped wave. The severest, grade "D-5 Black," includes a wave that has completely disappeared. The additional grade "D-X Gray" includes cases in which the baseline wave is undetectable. Postoperative motor deterioration was evaluated in the upper limbs (PUMD) and lower limbs (PLMD) individually.
PLMD only occurred in cases with more than a 90% wave amplitude decrease (from D-3 to D-5) and with the undetectable baseline wave (D-X). The PLMD rate increased according to the severity of the amplitude decreases (29% in D-3, 67% in D-4, 80% in D-5). Most PUMD occurred in cases with more than a 90% decrease, but one case with grade D1 had PUMD.
The seven-color graded alarm criterion supports surgeons' decisions on how to treat the wave amplitude decrease during surgery. It provides motor deterioration risk in each grade without false negatives. Moreover, the corresponding colors enable quick comprehension of the risks.
对于髓内脊髓肿瘤(IMSCT)手术,外科医生需要有关运动功能恶化风险的精确信息。然而,传统的皮层体感诱发电位(TcMsEP)警报标准提供的信息有限,只有单一的低于或高于警报标准,中间没有任何分级,导致出现假阴性和假阳性结果。因此,我们开发了一种用于神经监测的“七色TcMsEP分级系统”,以提供更多分级信息。本研究调查该系统的有效性。
本研究纳入了60例行IMSCT切除术的患者。TcMsEP结果分为七个等级:“D-0绿色”等级包括与基线振幅相比波幅下降0%-50%。“D-1酸橙色”等级包括下降50%-70%。“D-2黄色”等级包括下降70%-90%。“D-3橙色”等级包括下降超过90%且波形清晰可见。“D-4红色”等级包括最小且形状异常的波。最严重的“D-5黑色”等级包括完全消失的波。额外的“D-X灰色”等级包括无法检测到基线波的情况。分别对上肢(PUMD)和下肢(PLMD)的术后运动功能恶化进行评估。
PLMD仅发生在波幅下降超过90%(从D-3到D-5)以及基线波无法检测到(D-X)的病例中。PLMD发生率随着振幅下降的严重程度而增加(D-3中为29%,D-4中为67%,D-5中为80%)。大多数PUMD发生在下降超过90%的病例中,但有1例D1级患者出现了PUMD。
七色分级警报标准有助于外科医生决定如何处理手术期间的波幅下降。它提供了每个等级的运动功能恶化风险,且无假阴性。此外,相应的颜色能够使人们快速理解风险。