Department of Population Health, New York University Grossman School of Medicine, New York, New York, United States of America.
Center for Drug Use and HIV Research, New York University, New York, New York, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2021 Aug 26;16(8):e0256201. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0256201. eCollection 2021.
Although racial/ethnic disparities in police contact are well documented, less is known about other dimensions of inequity in policing. Sexual minority groups may face disproportionate police contact. We used data from the P18 Cohort Study (Version 2), a study conducted to measure determinants of inequity in STI/HIV risk among young sexual minority men (YSMM) in New York City, to measure across-time trends, racial/ethnic disparities, and correlates of self-reported stop-and-frisk experience over the cohort follow-up (2014-2019). Over the study period, 43% reported stop-and-frisk with higher levels reported among Black (47%) and Hispanic/Latinx (45%) than White (38%) participants. Stop-and-frisk levels declined over follow-up for each racial/ethnic group. The per capita rates among P18 participants calculated based on self-reported stop-and-frisk were much higher than rates calculated based on New York City Police Department official counts. We stratified respondents' ZIP codes of residence into tertiles of per capita stop rates and observed pronounced disparities in Black versus White stop-and-frisk rates, particularly in neighborhoods with low or moderate levels of stop-and-frisk activity. YSMM facing the greatest economic vulnerability and mental disorder symptoms were most likely to report stop-and-frisk. Among White respondents levels of past year stop-and-frisk were markedly higher among those who reported past 30 day marijuana use (41%) versus those reporting no use (17%) while among Black and Hispanic/Latinx respondents stop-and-frisk levels were comparable among those reporting marijuana use (38%) versus those reporting no use (31%). These findings suggest inequity in policing is observed not only among racial/ethnic but also sexual minority groups and that racial/ethnic YSMM, who are at the intersection of multiple minority statuses, face disproportionate risk. Because the most socially vulnerable experience disproportionate stop-and-frisk risk, we need to reach YSMM with community resources to promote health and wellbeing as an alternative to targeting this group with stressful and stigmatizing police exposure.
虽然警察接触方面的种族/民族差异有据可查,但关于警务中其他不平等方面的了解较少。性少数群体可能面临不成比例的警察接触。我们使用了来自 P18 队列研究(第 2 版)的数据,该研究旨在衡量纽约市年轻性少数男性(YSMM)中性传播感染/艾滋病毒风险不平等的决定因素,以衡量队列随访期间(2014-2019 年)自我报告的拦截和搜身经历的跨时间趋势、种族/民族差异和相关性。在研究期间,43%的人报告了拦截和搜身,其中黑人(47%)和西班牙裔/拉丁裔(45%)比白人(38%)参与者报告的水平更高。对于每个种族/民族群体,随访期间的拦截和搜身水平都有所下降。根据自我报告的拦截和搜身计算得出的 P18 参与者的人均率远高于根据纽约市警察局官方统计计算得出的比率。我们将受访者的居住邮政编码区分为人均拦截率的三分之一,并观察到黑人和白人之间的拦截和搜身率存在明显差异,特别是在拦截和搜身活动水平较低或中等的社区。面临最大经济脆弱性和精神障碍症状的 YSMM 最有可能报告拦截和搜身。在白人受访者中,过去一年中被拦截和搜身的比例在过去 30 天内报告使用大麻的受访者(41%)中明显高于未使用大麻的受访者(17%),而在黑人受访者和西班牙裔/拉丁裔受访者中,报告使用大麻的受访者(38%)和报告未使用大麻的受访者(31%)的拦截和搜身水平相当。这些发现表明,警务中的不平等不仅存在于种族/民族群体中,也存在于性少数群体中,处于多种少数群体地位交叉点的种族/民族 YSMM 面临不成比例的风险。由于最弱势的群体面临不成比例的拦截和搜身风险,我们需要用社区资源接触 YSMM,以促进健康和福祉,而不是通过对该群体进行有压力和污名化的警察接触来实现这一目标。