Butson Russell, John Senorita, Suazo Adan
University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand.
Med Sci Educ. 2020 May 6;30(2):917-925. doi: 10.1007/s40670-020-00974-5. eCollection 2020 Jun.
Learning through independent study is a core component of the university teaching method. Students are expected to invest substantial amounts of time in independent learning. However, many universities do not explicitly teach 'study' skills as part of formal instruction. This is due to the belief that students enter the university environment with a rudimentary but sound set of study practices. It is expected that students will hone these practices to a higher, more advanced level as they progress through their university education, although these deductions may not be as straightforward as assumed. This article presents an exploratory analysis of independent study practices employed by undergraduate health science students at a research-intensive university. The study design focused on three core areas: observations of study practices within a library setting, the act of note-taking and the student voice on study. Observations involved the use of continuous sampling over punctuated sessions to capture behavioural frequencies. Informal group discussions were used to gain the student voice regarding their perceptions of study. Finally, a number of students submitted copies of their approach to note-taking. The findings showed that for these students, (1) observation of library study practices revealed sustained study was generally poor, (2) that students perceived the programme compelled them to adopt superficial learning practices and (3) surprisingly, we found a number of these students had adopted a note-taking process that literately imitated textbook form.
自主学习是大学教学方法的核心组成部分。学生需要投入大量时间进行自主学习。然而,许多大学并没有将“学习”技能作为正式教学的一部分进行明确讲授。这是因为人们认为学生进入大学时已经具备一套基本但合理的学习方法。人们期望学生在大学教育过程中能够将这些方法提升到更高、更先进的水平,尽管这些推断可能不像设想的那么简单直接。本文对一所研究型大学的本科健康科学专业学生所采用的自主学习方法进行了探索性分析。该研究设计聚焦于三个核心领域:图书馆环境下学习方法的观察、做笔记的行为以及学生对学习的看法。观察涉及在间断时间段内使用连续抽样来获取行为频率。通过非正式小组讨论来了解学生对学习的看法。最后,一些学生提交了他们做笔记方法的副本。研究结果表明,对于这些学生来说,(1)对图书馆学习方法的观察显示持续学习普遍较差,(2)学生认为课程迫使他们采用表面的学习方法,(3)令人惊讶的是,我们发现这些学生中有许多人采用了一种完全模仿教科书形式的笔记记录过程。