McElvaney Rosaleen, Lateef Rusan, Collin-Vézina Delphine, Alaggia Ramona, Simpson Megan
Dublin City University, Dublin, Ireland.
McGill University, Montreal, Canada.
J Interpers Violence. 2022 Oct;37(19-20):NP18738-NP18760. doi: 10.1177/08862605211037435. Epub 2021 Aug 30.
Child sexual abuse (CSA) has been described as a highly stigmatizing experience. Despite the recognition of shame as a significant contributor to psychological distress following CSA, an inhibitor of CSA disclosure, and a challenging emotion to overcome in therapy, limited research has explored the experience of shame with young people who have been sexually abused. This study is unique in examining the transcripts of 47 young people aged 15-25 years from a large-scale study conducted in Ireland and Canada and exploring manifestations of shame in CSA disclosure narratives. Using a thematic analysis of both inductive and deductive coding, the data were examined for implicit, as distinct from explicit, manifestations of shame. Three key themes were identified in this study: languaging shame, avoiding shame, and reducing shame. The study supports previous authors in highlighting the need for nuanced measures of shame in research that takes account of the complexity of this emotion. Conceptualizations in the literature of the distinction between shame and guilt are challenged when these emotions are explored in the context of CSA. Finally, recommendations for working therapeutically with young people who have experienced CSA are offered with a view to addressing shame in therapeutic work.
儿童性虐待(CSA)被描述为一种极具污名化的经历。尽管人们认识到羞耻感是CSA后心理困扰的重要促成因素、CSA披露的一种阻碍,以及治疗中难以克服的一种情绪,但针对遭受性虐待的年轻人的羞耻经历的研究却很有限。本研究的独特之处在于,它审视了来自爱尔兰和加拿大的一项大规模研究中47名15至25岁年轻人的访谈记录,并探究了CSA披露叙述中羞耻感的表现形式。通过对归纳编码和演绎编码进行主题分析,研究了羞耻感的隐性(与显性相对)表现形式。本研究确定了三个关键主题:表达羞耻感、回避羞耻感和减轻羞耻感。该研究支持了之前的作者所强调的观点,即在研究中需要有细致入微的羞耻感衡量方法,要考虑到这种情绪的复杂性。当在CSA背景下探究羞耻感和内疚感之间的区别时,文献中的概念化观点受到了挑战。最后,针对如何与遭受CSA的年轻人进行治疗工作提出了建议,以期在治疗工作中解决羞耻感问题。