Malpractice litigation and spinal surgery in the National Health Service: a single tertiary-level centre perspective over 12 years.

INTRODUCTION

Medical malpractice litigation is a major concern for all spine surgeons. Our aim was to evaluate the incidence and burden of successful litigation relating to the management of spinal disorders over 12 years within a UK NHS tertiary-level spinal unit and compare these litigation costs with those of other specialties.

METHODS

We obtained all data held by our claims department from its inception in January 2008 to December 2019. We also obtained costs for the total financial burden incurred by our Trust during this period.

RESULTS

In total, there were 83 closed claims involving spinal pathologies. Over 80% of these comprised negligent surgery (= 28, 34%), delay to diagnose/treat (= 25, 30%) and negligent care (= 18, 22%). The vast majority of claims were withdrawn without incurring any cost to the hospital (= 59, 71%) and only 24 (29%) resulted in successful litigation for the claimant. The total cost of damages for these 24 successful claims was just over £8 million, including legal costs of £2.5 million, out of total litigation costs of £381 million over this period.

DISCUSSION

Fewer than 30% of initial claims against a tertiary spinal surgical referral unit resulted in a successful financial outcome for the claimant. The total costs incurred were just over £8 million, with one-third apportioned to high legal costs, reflecting the complexity of resolving spinal litigation. Our entire legal expenses accounted for only 2% of the total legal bill paid by our hospital over a 12-year period.