School of Health Sciences, Robert Gordon University, Aberdeen, UK.
The Scottish Centre for Evidence-based, Multi-professional Practice: A JBI Centre of Excellence, Aberdeen, UK.
JBI Evid Synth. 2021 Nov 1;19(11):2958-2992. doi: 10.11124/JBIES-20-00340.
The purpose of this review was to identify, map, and describe the characteristics of student-led physical rehabilitation groups and clinics in entry-level health education.
Student-led groups and clinics for physical rehabilitation are an emergent phenomenon in entry-level health professional education. Data gathered in this scoping review aimed to provide an understanding of the range and scope of student-led groups and clinics within a physical rehabilitation context, and establish the evaluation undertaken to date from a student, service user, and stakeholder perspective. It also aimed to identify other important factors in the design, execution, and feasibility of the concept. Finally, it aimed to identify gaps in the literature that can be addressed by further research.
This scoping review considered studies and sources that identify student-led methods for carrying out physical rehabilitation for service users in either an exercise group or clinic environment. Students and groups/clinics on entry-level qualifying courses were considered. The review considered primary and secondary research in any paradigm as well as text and opinion articles.
The JBI methodology for conducting scoping reviews was employed. The following databases were searched: MEDLINE, CINAHL, AMED, ERIC, Scopus, and SPORTDiscus. Searches were limited from January 1, 1998, to the date of the search (November 1, 2019). Non-English articles were excluded. To supplement the review, searches for gray literature were also undertaken. Data extraction was performed by two reviewers using a pre-determined data extraction form developed by the authors. The results of the review are presented in narrative form and supported by tables and figures.
This review identified 523 sources of information of which 111 were screened at full-text stage and 48 sources were eligible to be included in the final scoping review. A wide range of student-led groups and clinics that provide physical rehabilitation exist globally. Drivers for the clinics and groups vary; key aims included providing a learning environment for student skill development, serving as clinical placements, and providing a social enterprise. Evaluations focused on student experience, service user experience, and cost-benefit analyses.
Student-led groups and clinics are at different stages of development and use within entry-level curricula. The objectives and drivers for groups and clinics vary worldwide; therefore, the evolution of groups and clinics has driven a wide range and number of models globally.
本综述的目的是确定、绘制和描述入门级健康教育中学生主导的物理康复小组和诊所的特征。
学生主导的物理康复小组和诊所是入门级健康专业教育中的一个新兴现象。本综述中收集的数据旨在了解物理康复背景下学生主导的小组和诊所的范围,并从学生、服务使用者和利益相关者的角度确定迄今为止进行的评估。它还旨在确定概念设计、执行和可行性方面的其他重要因素。最后,它旨在确定可以通过进一步研究解决的文献中的差距。
本范围综述考虑了确定学生主导的方法,用于为服务使用者提供锻炼小组或诊所环境中的物理康复的研究和来源。考虑了入门级资格课程的学生和小组/诊所。综述考虑了任何范式的主要和次要研究以及文本和观点文章。
采用 JBI 方法进行范围综述。检索了以下数据库:MEDLINE、CINAHL、AMED、ERIC、Scopus 和 SPORTDiscus。搜索范围从 1998 年 1 月 1 日到搜索日期(2019 年 11 月 1 日)。不包括非英语文章。为了补充综述,还进行了灰色文献搜索。数据提取由两位作者使用预先确定的数据提取表格进行。综述结果以叙述形式呈现,并通过表格和图形提供支持。
本综述共确定了 523 条信息来源,其中 111 条在全文阶段进行了筛选,48 条符合最终范围综述的纳入标准。全球范围内存在各种提供物理康复的学生主导小组和诊所。诊所和小组的驱动因素各不相同;主要目标包括为学生技能发展提供学习环境、作为临床实习场所以及提供社会企业。评估侧重于学生体验、服务使用者体验和成本效益分析。
学生主导的小组和诊所处于入门级课程中不同的发展和使用阶段。全球范围内小组和诊所的目标和驱动因素各不相同;因此,小组和诊所的发展推动了全球范围内各种模型的出现。