Francone Nicolás O, Simon Melissa A, Ortega Pilar
Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine and the Robert H. Lurie Comprehensive Cancer Center, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
Health Equity. 2021 Aug 16;5(1):526-533. doi: 10.1089/heq.2021.0026. eCollection 2021.
Efforts to increase U.S. medical school student diversity have lagged behind the continued growth of racial/ethnic minorities in the population. A targeted, local approach may catalyze actionable change that holds schools accountable for addressing community needs through representation. The aims of our study are to (1) analyze the student racial/ethnic profiles of allopathic and osteopathic medical schools in the diverse state of Illinois and (2) compare student race/ethnicity with that of schools' local county and primary teaching hospital patient populations. Data from the Association of American Medical Colleges and American Association of College of Osteopathic Medicine were used to gather matriculated student race/ethnicity from the eight allopathic schools and one osteopathic medical school in Illinois. Representational inequity quotients (RIQs) were calculated to determine the proportion of Hispanic/Latinx, black/African American, and total underrepresented in medicine (UIM) individuals in three reference populations (U.S., county, and primary teaching hospital patient populations) relative to each medical school's student racial/ethnic profile. Across Illinois schools, mean RIQs were highest (showed greater inequity) when county demographics were used as the reference population as opposed to U.S. or hospital populations. For all schools individually, Hispanic county-student RIQs were higher than RIQs based on hospital population. For a majority of schools with primary teaching hospital in Cook County, hospital-student RIQs magnified representational inequity for the black population. Using county data to evaluate medical school representation inequities may better reflect UIM representation goals than the U.S. population. Examining hospital demographics may further reveal other structural inequities relevant to medical education, such as primary teaching hospitals that are not adequately serving their surrounding communities. By evaluating RIQs on a local and hospital-population level, schools can periodically assess to what degree their student body and hospital populations represent their communities and adjust recruitment, retention, and service efforts.
增加美国医学院学生多样性的努力落后于人口中种族/族裔少数群体的持续增长。一种有针对性的地方方法可能会促成可采取行动的变革,使学校通过代表性来为满足社区需求负责。我们研究的目的是:(1)分析伊利诺伊州这个多元化州内的全科医学和骨病医学学校的学生种族/族裔概况;(2)将学生的种族/族裔与学校所在县以及主要教学医院的患者群体的种族/族裔进行比较。美国医学院协会和美国骨病医学院协会的数据被用于收集伊利诺伊州八所全科医学学校和一所骨病医学学校录取学生的种族/族裔信息。计算代表性不平等商数(RIQs),以确定在三个参考人群(美国、县和主要教学医院患者群体)中,西班牙裔/拉丁裔、黑人/非裔美国人以及医学领域总体代表性不足(UIM)个体相对于每所医学院学生种族/族裔概况的比例。在伊利诺伊州的各所学校中,与以美国或医院人群作为参考人群相比,以县人口统计数据作为参考人群时,平均RIQs最高(显示出更大的不平等)。对于每一所学校而言,西班牙裔县-学生RIQs高于基于医院人群的RIQs。对于大多数在库克县设有主要教学医院的学校,医院-学生RIQs放大了黑人人口的代表性不平等。使用县数据评估医学院的代表性不平等可能比美国人口数据更能反映UIM代表性目标。研究医院人口统计数据可能会进一步揭示与医学教育相关的其他结构性不平等,比如主要教学医院未能充分服务其周边社区。通过在地方和医院人群层面评估RIQs,学校可以定期评估其学生群体和医院人群在多大程度上代表了他们的社区,并调整招生、留校和服务工作。