Maister Nicholas J, Hely Andrew, Twycross Liam G, Gill Stephen D, Page Richard S
Barwon Centre for Orthopaedic Research and Education, St John of God Hospital, Geelong, Victoria, Australia.
Department of Orthopaedics, Barwon Health, University Hospital, Geelong, Victoria, Australia.
J Shoulder Elb Arthroplast. 2020 May 21;4:2471549220926826. doi: 10.1177/2471549220926826. eCollection 2020.
The most effective method and modality for measuring glenoid version for different shoulder conditions is uncertain. Computed tomography (CT) imaging exposes the patient to radiation, and standard magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) does not consistently image the entire scapula. This study investigates the reliability of a new method for assessing glenoid version using routine shoulder MRI.
MRI images of 20 patients undergoing arthroscopy for shoulder instability were independently assessed by 3 clinicians for osseous and chondrolabral glenoid version. To assess glenoid version, a line was drawn from medial corner of the glenoid body to midpoint of the glenoid face. A line perpendicular to this was the reference against which to measure glenoid version. Measurements were repeated after 3 months to assess intra- and interobserver reliability. Reliability was determined using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs).
Interclass correlation coefficients showed at least good reliability for most estimates of intraobserver reliability (ICC ≥ .66) and excellent reliability for most estimates of interobserver reliability (ICC ≥ .84), with the exception of some inferior glenoid measurements where ICC was poor (ICC ≤.41).
We propose that this new method of measuring glenoid on standard axial MRI can be used as a simple, practical, and reliable method in shoulder instability patients, which will reduce the requirement for CT in this group.
对于不同肩部疾病,测量肩胛盂版本的最有效方法和方式尚不确定。计算机断层扫描(CT)成像会使患者暴露于辐射中,而标准磁共振成像(MRI)并不能始终对整个肩胛骨进行成像。本研究调查了一种使用常规肩部MRI评估肩胛盂版本的新方法的可靠性。
3名临床医生对20例因肩部不稳定接受关节镜检查的患者的MRI图像进行独立评估,以确定骨性和软骨盂唇的肩胛盂版本。为了评估肩胛盂版本,从肩胛盂体的内侧角向肩胛盂面的中点画一条线。与此垂直的线作为测量肩胛盂版本的参考线。3个月后重复测量以评估观察者内和观察者间的可靠性。使用组内相关系数(ICC)确定可靠性。
组内相关系数显示,大多数观察者内可靠性估计至少具有良好的可靠性(ICC≥0.66),大多数观察者间可靠性估计具有出色的可靠性(ICC≥0.84),但一些肩胛盂下部测量的ICC较差(ICC≤0.41)除外。
我们建议,这种在标准轴向MRI上测量肩胛盂的新方法可作为肩部不稳定患者一种简单、实用且可靠的方法,这将减少该组患者对CT的需求。