From the Department of Anesthesiology and Critical Care Medicine, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland.
Department of Anesthesiology, University of Colorado School of Medicine, Aurora, Colorado.
Anesth Analg. 2021 Dec 1;133(6):1497-1509. doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000005740.
Research has shown that women have leadership ability equal to or better than that of their male counterparts, yet proportionally fewer women than men achieve leadership positions and promotion in medicine. The Women's Empowerment and Leadership Initiative (WELI) was founded within the Society for Pediatric Anesthesia (SPA) in 2018 as a multidimensional program to help address the significant career development, leadership, and promotion gender gap between men and women in anesthesiology. Herein, we describe WELI's development and implementation with an early assessment of effectiveness at 2 years. Members received an anonymous, voluntary survey by e-mail to assess whether they believed WELI was beneficial in several broad domains: career development, networking, project implementation and completion, goal setting, mentorship, well-being, and promotion and leadership. The response rate was 60.5% (92 of 152). The majority ranked several aspects of WELI to be very or extremely valuable, including the protégé-advisor dyads, workshops, nomination to join WELI, and virtual facilitated networking. For most members, WELI helped to improve optimism about their professional future. Most also reported that WELI somewhat or absolutely contributed to project improvement or completion, finding new collaborators, and obtaining invitations to be visiting speakers. Among those who applied for promotion or leadership positions, 51% found WELI to be somewhat or absolutely valuable to their application process, and 42% found the same in applying for leadership positions. Qualitative analysis of free-text survey responses identified 5 main themes: (1) feelings of empowerment and confidence, (2) acquisition of new skills in mentoring, coaching, career development, and project implementation, (3) clarification and focus on goal setting, (4) creating meaningful connections through networking, and (5) challenges from coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) and the inability to sustain the advisor-protégé connection. We conclude that after 2 years, the WELI program has successfully supported career development for the majority of protégés and advisors. Continued assessment of whether WELI can meaningfully contribute to attainment of promotion and leadership positions will require study across a longer period. WELI could serve as a programmatic example to support women's career development in other subspecialties.
研究表明,女性的领导能力与男性相当,甚至优于男性,但在医学领域,实现领导职位晋升的女性比例却低于男性。2018 年,儿科麻醉学会(SPA)成立了女性赋权和领导力倡议(WELI),这是一个多维度的项目,旨在帮助解决麻醉领域男女之间显著的职业发展、领导力和晋升性别差距问题。本文描述了 WELI 的发展和实施情况,并在 2 年后对其早期效果进行了评估。通过电子邮件向成员发送了匿名自愿调查,以评估他们是否认为 WELI 在以下几个广泛领域有益:职业发展、人际关系网、项目实施和完成、目标设定、指导、健康和福祉以及晋升和领导力。回复率为 60.5%(92 名成员中的 92 名)。大多数人认为 WELI 的几个方面非常有价值或极具价值,包括导师-学员二人组、研讨会、提名加入 WELI 和虚拟促进网络。对大多数成员来说,WELI 有助于改善他们对职业未来的乐观态度。大多数人还报告说,WELI 在项目改进或完成、寻找新的合作伙伴以及获得客座演讲邀请方面有所帮助。在申请晋升或领导职位的人员中,51%的人认为 WELI 对其申请过程有一定的帮助,42%的人认为在申请领导职位时也是如此。对调查中自由文本的定性分析确定了 5 个主要主题:(1)赋权和信心的感觉;(2)获得辅导、指导、职业发展和项目实施方面的新技能;(3)明确和专注于目标设定;(4)通过人际关系网建立有意义的联系;(5)受到 2019 年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)的挑战和无法维持导师-学员关系。我们的结论是,在 2 年后,WELI 项目成功地为大多数学员和导师的职业发展提供了支持。需要进一步研究,以确定 WELI 是否能对晋升和领导职位的获得产生有意义的影响。WELI 可以作为一个项目范例,在其他专科领域支持女性的职业发展。