Ellyin Alexander, Day Kelli, Samuel Jacqueline, Bartell Tami, McGill Dion, Sheehan Karen, Levin Rebecca
Ann & Robert H. Lurie Children's Hospital of Chicago, 225 E. Chicago Avenue, Chicago, IL, 60611, USA.
National Louis University, 122 S. Michigan Avenue, Chicago, IL, 60603, USA.
Inj Epidemiol. 2021 Sep 13;8(Suppl 1):39. doi: 10.1186/s40621-021-00335-9.
Chicago has a history of gun violence with some neighborhoods, particularly Black and Brown communities, being disproportionately affected and Black male youth experiencing an even more disparate impact. Too often, violence prevention research is developed and carried out with little or no input from the people living in the most affected communities. The objective of the Community-Academic Collaboration to Prevent Violence in Chicago (CACPVC) was to bring together individuals from impacted communities with academic researchers and other community stakeholders to discuss violence and co-create a research agenda that addresses topics of mutual concern, and recommendations for engaging stakeholders including community members and organizations and funders in violence and violence prevention research.
From 2014 to 2015, community members and organizations from seven defined regions across Chicago were recruited to participate. An organization network gathering was held in each region for researchers, funders, and community organization representatives to discuss violence prevention. Open community forums then took place in each community. Violence data by region was shared followed by facilitated group discussions that were recorded by youth scribes. Notes were thematically coded, grouped, and compiled after which a list of topics was refined by the CACPVC Work Group, allowing for investigator triangulation. A survey was disseminated to community stakeholders to prioritize the topics.
Seven network gatherings (127 attendees) and community forums (133 attendees) were held. Topic areas identified during the gatherings and forums included root causes/cycle of violence, racism and bias/structural violence, trajectory of violence, protective factors and nonviolence, geographic pattern change, violence prevention strategies, youth, family factors, community factors, school, police, gangs/street organizations, and media and public perceptions. Recommendations to support community engagement were grouped as role of research in reducing violence, role of community in violence research, relationships and respect, academic-community communication, financial considerations, training, practical considerations, research design, sharing results, communication about and use of data, and recommendations for funders.
The violence research agenda will be used to inform community-engaged violence prevention research. The recommendations for community engagement provide a resource for researchers about topics to consider to meaningfully engage community members in future research.
芝加哥有着枪支暴力的历史,一些社区,尤其是黑人和棕色人种社区,受到的影响尤为严重,而黑人男性青年受到的影响更为悬殊。预防暴力的研究往往在很少或根本没有受影响最严重社区居民参与的情况下开展和实施。芝加哥预防暴力社区 - 学术合作组织(CACPVC)的目标是将受影响社区的个人与学术研究人员及其他社区利益相关者聚集在一起,讨论暴力问题,并共同制定一个研究议程,以解决共同关心的话题,并就如何让包括社区成员、组织和资助者在内的利益相关者参与暴力及暴力预防研究提出建议。
2014年至2015年,招募了来自芝加哥七个特定区域的社区成员和组织参与。在每个区域都举行了一次组织网络聚会,让研究人员﹑资助者和社区组织代表讨论暴力预防问题。随后在每个社区举办了开放的社区论坛。分享了各区域的暴力数据,接着进行由青年记录员记录的小组讨论。笔记经过主题编码、分组和整理,之后由CACPVC工作组完善主题列表,以便进行调查三角互证。向社区利益相关者发放了一份调查问卷,以确定主题的优先顺序。
举行了七次网络聚会(127名与会者)和社区论坛(133名与会者)。在聚会和论坛期间确定 的主题领域包括暴力的根本原因/循环、种族主义和偏见/结构性暴力、暴力轨迹、保护因素和非暴力、地理模式变化、暴力预防策略、青年、家庭因素、社区因素、学校、警察、帮派/街头组织以及媒体和公众认知。支持社区参与的建议分为研究在减少暴力中的作用、社区在暴力研究中的作用、关系与尊重、学术 - 社区沟通、财务考量、培训、实际考量、研究设计、分享结果、数据的沟通与使用以及给资助者的建议。
暴力研究议程将用于为社区参与的暴力预防研究提供信息。社区参与的建议为研究人员提供了一种资源,有助于他们思考在未来研究中如何让社区成员切实参与进来。