Department of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, Hippokration General Hospital of Thessaloniki, Konstantinoupoleos 49, Postal Code 546 42, Thessaloniki, Greece.
Laboratory of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology (Medical Law and Ethics), School of Medicine, Faculty of Health Sciences, Aristotle University, University Campus, Postal Code 541 24, Thessaloniki, Greece.
BMC Psychiatry. 2021 Sep 22;21(1):461. doi: 10.1186/s12888-021-03471-0.
A subset of adolescents with mental disorders are likely to have decision-making capacity that facilitates their therapy engagement. However, there are high rates of drop-out in mental health settings.
This study aims to identify perceived barriers to or facilitators of mental health care engagement among adolescents with decision-making competence in Greece.
A qualitative study was conducted using semi-structured interviews of adolescents with a wide range of mental health problems. In addition, two psychometric assessment measures were used to define who to include or exclude from the study sample.
Positive attitudes and experiences with therapy were reported as strong ("major") facilitators of therapy engagement for adolescents with mental disorders, whereas negative experiences with therapy were reported as strong barriers to it. Furthermore, and most importantly, a "good" adolescent-therapist relationship was reported as a strong facilitator, whereas negative experiences of participants with their therapist were reported as strong barriers. Moreover, goals such as getting rid of symptoms, improving personal well-being, and improving social skills and relationships (especially with peers) emerged as strong facilitators of therapy engagement. Importantly, the early remission of symptoms emerged from the study as a strong barrier to therapy engagement for participants. Among the weaker ("minor") perceived facilitators were goals such as confessing to a trustworthy person, becoming able to achieve personal expectations and life goals, enhancing independence and self-esteem, and developing a positive self-image. The (active or supportive) role of family emerged as a facilitator. The stigma related to mental health emerged as both a ("minor") facilitator of and barrier to therapy engagement for participants. Friends were reported as having a role ranging from neutral to mildly supportive.
A number of more or less strong barriers and facilitators were identified that, for the most part, were consistent with prior literature. However, the authors identified some nuances that are of clinical importance. For instance, adolescents are most likely to terminate the treatment prematurely if they experience early symptom remission. Highlighting the role of therapy in achieving their goals or improving their families' well-being might be used by therapists to reduce the attrition rate.
有一部分患有精神障碍的青少年可能具有促进其接受治疗的决策能力。然而,在精神卫生机构中,患者中途退出治疗的比例很高。
本研究旨在识别希腊具有决策能力的青少年在接受精神卫生保健服务时遇到的障碍或促进因素。
采用半结构式访谈法对患有各种精神健康问题的青少年进行了定性研究。此外,还使用了两种心理测量评估工具来确定谁应被纳入或排除在研究样本之外。
积极的治疗态度和经验被报告为患有精神障碍的青少年接受治疗的强烈(“主要”)促进因素,而治疗方面的负面经历则被报告为主要障碍。此外,最重要的是,“良好”的青少年与治疗师的关系被报告为一个强有力的促进因素,而参与者对治疗师的负面体验则被报告为一个强有力的障碍。此外,摆脱症状、改善个人幸福感、改善社交技能和人际关系(尤其是与同龄人)等目标被认为是治疗参与的强烈促进因素。重要的是,症状的早期缓解是参与者治疗参与的一个强烈障碍。被认为是较弱(“次要”)促进因素的目标包括向可信赖的人坦白、能够实现个人期望和生活目标、增强独立性和自尊心以及培养积极的自我形象。家庭的(积极或支持)作用被认为是一个促进因素。精神健康方面的污名被认为是参与者治疗参与的一个(次要)促进因素和障碍。朋友被认为具有从中立到轻度支持的作用。
确定了一些或多或少强烈的障碍和促进因素,这些因素在很大程度上与先前的文献一致。然而,作者还发现了一些具有临床意义的细微差别。例如,如果青少年在早期症状缓解后过早终止治疗,他们最有可能提前终止治疗。强调治疗在实现目标或改善家庭幸福感方面的作用,可能会被治疗师用来降低流失率。