Gordon M, Newbrun E
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 1986 Apr;14(2):104-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0528.1986.tb01507.x.
We compared DMFT (decayed, missing and filled teeth) values of young adult populations (about 18- to 21 yr old) obtained over two decades in five industrialized countries (Denmark, Finland, Israel, Japan, U.S.A.). Trends of the active disease factor (D) and treatment factor (F) within and between these countries during two decades were also compared. No uniform trend in caries prevalence data, based on total DMFT scores, was found. In some countries DMFT scores declined (Denmark, U.S.A.), in some they remained relatively static (Finland), and in some they increased during the last 20 yr (Israel, Japan). However, DMFT scores did not always correlate with untreated lesions, D, which decreased remarkably in Denmark and Finland and moderately in the U.S.A., remained stable in Japan, but increased in Israel. Similarly, treatment of caries, F, varied in different countries, increasing dramatically in Finland and Japan and moderately in Israel, remaining static in Denmark, and decreasing in the U.S.A. These trends appear to be influenced largely by the extent of caries-preventive measures (particularly fluorides) in the respective countries, and to a lesser degree by sugar utilization and the availability of dental personnel. This age population has not been studied in a comparative fashion previously. This study also emphasizes the importance of looking not only at DMFT scores but at the trends in meeting treatment needs, D vs F scores.
我们比较了五个工业化国家(丹麦、芬兰、以色列、日本、美国)在二十多年间获得的年轻成年人群(约18至21岁)的龋失补指数(DMFT,即龋、失、补牙数)值。还比较了这二十年间这些国家内部以及国家之间的活跃疾病因子(D)和治疗因子(F)的趋势。基于总DMFT得分,未发现龋齿患病率数据的统一趋势。在一些国家,DMFT得分下降(丹麦、美国),在一些国家保持相对稳定(芬兰),而在一些国家,在过去20年中得分上升(以色列、日本)。然而,DMFT得分并不总是与未治疗的病变(D)相关,D在丹麦和芬兰显著下降,在美国中度下降,在日本保持稳定,但在以色列上升。同样,龋齿治疗(F)在不同国家有所不同,在芬兰和日本大幅增加,在以色列中度增加,在丹麦保持不变,在美国下降。这些趋势似乎在很大程度上受各国龋病预防措施(特别是氟化物)的程度影响,在较小程度上受糖的摄入量和牙科人员的可获得性影响。此前尚未以比较的方式对这个年龄组人群进行研究。本研究还强调了不仅要关注DMFT得分,还要关注满足治疗需求的趋势(D与F得分)的重要性。