Department of Radiology, Severance Hospital, Research Institute of Radiological Science, Yonsei University College of Medicine, 50-1 Yonsei-ro, Seodaemun-gu, Seoul 03722, Korea.
Department of Biomedical Systems Informatics, Biostatistics Collaboration Unit, Yonsei University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2022 Mar;218(3):484-493. doi: 10.2214/AJR.21.26677. Epub 2021 Sep 29.
The LI-RADS treatment response algorithm may lack sufficient sensitivity for viable tumor after locoregional treatment (LRT) for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). The purpose of our study was to evaluate the impact of incorporation of ancillary MRI features on the diagnostic performance of the LI-RADS treatment response algorithm after LRT for HCC. This retrospective study included 141 patients (114 men, 27 women; median age, 56 years) who underwent gadoxetic acid-enhanced MRI after LRT for HCC between October 2005 and January 2020 and subsequent liver surgery. Two readers assessed lesions for LI-RADS features of viability for ancillary MRI features (transitional phase [TP] hypointensity, hepatobiliary phase [HBP] hypointensity, DWI hyperintensity or low ADC, and mild-to-moderate T2 hyperintensity). Interobserver agreement was assessed before reaching consensus. Significant ancillary features were identified using random forest analysis. The impact of incorporation of significant ancillary features on diagnostic performance for incomplete pathologic necrosis (IPN; pathologically viable tumor > 0 mm) was assessed using McNemar tests. Complete pathologic necrosis (CPN) was observed in 88 of 181 (48.6%) lesions. Interreader agreement was almost perfect for LI-RADS features of viability (κ = 0.92-0.97) and was substantial to almost perfect for ancillary features (κ = 0.73-0.94). Random forest analysis identified TP hypointensity (present in 8.0%, 25.0%, and 75.3% of lesions with CPN, viable tumor < 10 mm, and viable tumor ≥ 10 mm, respectively) and HBP hypointensity (9.2%, 25.0%, and 74.0%, respectively) as significant ancillary features. For detecting IPN, LR-TR (treatment response) Viable or LR-TR Equivocal had higher sensitivity than LR-TR Viable (71.0% vs 57.0%, respectively; = .001) but had lower specificity (86.4% vs 94.3%, = .02). However, LR-TR Viable or LR-TR Equivocal and TP hypointensity showed higher sensitivity than LR-TR Viable (64.5% vs 57.0%, = .02) without a significantly different specificity (90.9% vs 94.3%, = .25). LR-TR Viable or LR-TR Equivocal and HBP hypointensity also showed higher sensitivity than LR-TR Viable (65.6% vs 57.0%, = .01) without a significantly different specificity (90.8% vs 94.3%, = .25). TP hypointensity and HBP hypointensity increase the sensitivity of LI-RADS treatment response algorithm for viable tumor without lowering specificity. The two identified ancillary features may improve tumor viability assessment and planning of additional therapies after LRT for HCC.
LI-RADS 治疗后反应算法在 HCC 局部治疗后(LRT)可能对存活肿瘤缺乏足够的敏感性。本研究的目的是评估在 HCC LRT 后,辅助 MRI 特征对 LI-RADS 治疗后反应算法诊断性能的影响。本回顾性研究纳入了 141 名患者(114 名男性,27 名女性;中位年龄 56 岁),这些患者在 HCC LRT 后于 2005 年 10 月至 2020 年 1 月接受了钆塞酸增强 MRI 检查,并随后进行了肝脏手术。两名读者评估了 LI-RADS 对辅助 MRI 特征(过渡期[TP]低信号、肝胆期[HBP]低信号、DWI 高信号或 ADC 低信号、T2 轻度至中度高信号)的存活肿瘤特征。在达成共识之前,评估了观察者间的一致性。使用随机森林分析确定显著的辅助特征。使用 McNemar 检验评估纳入显著辅助特征对不完全病理性坏死(IPN;病理性存活肿瘤>0mm)的诊断性能的影响。181 个病灶中,88 个(48.6%)观察到完全病理性坏死(CPN)。LI-RADS 存活肿瘤特征的观察者间一致性几乎完美(κ=0.92-0.97),辅助特征的一致性为中等至几乎完美(κ=0.73-0.94)。随机森林分析确定 TP 低信号(CPN 中分别为 8.0%、25.0%和 75.3%,存活肿瘤<10mm、存活肿瘤≥10mm)和 HBP 低信号(9.2%、25.0%和 74.0%)为显著的辅助特征。对于检测 IPN,LR-TR(治疗反应)存活或 LR-TR 不确定的敏感性高于 LR-TR 存活(71.0%比 57.0%,P=0.001),但特异性较低(86.4%比 94.3%,P=0.02)。然而,LR-TR 存活或 LR-TR 不确定和 TP 低信号的敏感性高于 LR-TR 存活(64.5%比 57.0%,P=0.02),特异性无显著差异(90.9%比 94.3%,P=0.25)。LR-TR 存活或 LR-TR 不确定和 HBP 低信号的敏感性也高于 LR-TR 存活(65.6%比 57.0%,P=0.01),特异性无显著差异(90.8%比 94.3%,P=0.25)。TP 低信号和 HBP 低信号增加了 LI-RADS 治疗反应算法对存活肿瘤的敏感性,而特异性无显著降低。这两个确定的辅助特征可能会提高 HCC LRT 后肿瘤存活能力的评估,并计划进一步治疗。