Jorge Ana Elisa Serafim, Bennell Kim Louise, Kimp Alexander Jared, Campbell Penny Kate, Hinman Rana Shane
Center for Biological and Health Sciences, Department of Physiotherapy, Federal University of São Carlos, São Paulo, Brazil.
Centre for Health, Exercise and Sports Medicine, Department of Physiotherapy, School of Health Sciences, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
JMIR Med Educ. 2021 Dec 1;7(4):e30378. doi: 10.2196/30378.
The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated clinicians to transition to telehealth, often with little preparation or training. The Physiotherapy Exercise and Physical Activity for Knee Osteoarthritis (PEAK) e-learning modules were developed to upskill physiotherapists in management of knee osteoarthritis (OA) via telehealth and in-person. In the research setting, the e-learning modules are perceived by physiotherapists as effective when they are part of a comprehensive training program for a clinical trial. However, the effectiveness of the modules on their own in a real-world setting is unknown.
This study aims to evaluate the reach, effectiveness, adoption, and implementation of PEAK e-learning modules.
This longitudinal study was informed by the Reach, Effectiveness, Adoption, Implementation, and Maintenance (RE-AIM) framework. Participants were clinicians, researchers, educators, and health care students who registered for access to the modules between April 1 and November 30, 2020. Reach was evaluated by outcomes (countries, referral sources, and attrition) extracted from registration data and embedded within precourse surveys in the Learning Management System (LMS). Effectiveness was evaluated by outcomes (confidence with videoconferencing; likelihood of using education, strengthening exercise, and physical activity in a treatment plan for knee OA; usefulness of modules) measured using a 10-point numeric rating scale (NRS; score range from 1=not confident or likely or useful at all to 10=extremely confident or likely or useful) in pre- and postcourse (on completion) surveys in the LMS. Adoption and implementation were evaluated by demographic and professional characteristics and outcomes related to the use of learning and usefulness of program elements (measured via a 4-point Likert scale, from not at all useful to extremely useful) in a survey administered 4 months after module completion.
Broad reach was achieved, with 6720 people from 97 countries registering for access. Among registrants, there were high levels of attrition, with 36.65% (2463/6720) commencing the program and precourse survey and 19.61% (1318/6720) completing all modules and the postcourse survey. The program was effective. Learners who completed the modules demonstrated increased confidence with videoconferencing (mean change 3.1, 95% CI 3.0-3.3 NRS units) and increased likelihood of using education, strengthening and physical activity in a knee OA treatment plan, compared to precourse. Adoption and implementation of learning (n=149 respondents) occurred at 4 months. More than half of the respondents used their learning to structure in-person consultations with patients (80/142, 56.3%) and patient information booklets in their clinical practice (75/142, 52.8%).
Findings provide evidence of the reach and effectiveness of an asynchronous self-directed e-learning program in a real-world setting among physiotherapists. The e-learning modules offer clinicians an accessible educational course to learn about best-practice knee OA management, including telehealth delivery via videoconferencing. Attrition across the e-learning program highlights the challenges of keeping learners engaged in self-directed web-based learning.
2019年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行迫使临床医生转向远程医疗,而他们往往几乎没有准备或培训。膝关节骨关节炎的物理治疗运动与身体活动(PEAK)电子学习模块旨在提升物理治疗师通过远程医疗和面对面方式管理膝关节骨关节炎(OA)的技能。在研究环境中,当电子学习模块成为临床试验综合培训计划的一部分时,物理治疗师认为其是有效的。然而,这些模块在现实环境中单独使用的有效性尚不清楚。
本研究旨在评估PEAK电子学习模块的覆盖范围、有效性、采用情况和实施情况。
本纵向研究以覆盖范围、有效性、采用情况、实施情况和维持情况(RE-AIM)框架为依据。参与者为2020年4月1日至11月30日期间注册访问这些模块的临床医生、研究人员、教育工作者和医护专业学生。通过从注册数据中提取并嵌入学习管理系统(LMS)课前调查中的结果(国家、推荐来源和流失情况)来评估覆盖范围。通过在LMS的课前和课后(完成时)调查中使用10分数字评分量表(NRS;分数范围从1=完全不自信或不可能或无用至10=极其自信或可能或有用)测量的结果(对视频会议的信心;在膝关节OA治疗计划中使用教育、强化运动和身体活动的可能性;模块的有用性)来评估有效性。在模块完成4个月后进行的一项调查中,通过人口统计学和专业特征以及与学习使用和项目要素有用性相关联的结果(通过4分量表测量,从不有用至极其有用)来评估采用情况和实施情况。
实现了广泛覆盖,来自97个国家的6720人注册访问。在注册者中,流失率很高,36.65%(2463/6720)开始该计划并参与课前调查,19.61%(1318/6720)完成所有模块和课后调查。该计划是有效的。与课前相比,完成模块的学习者对视频会议的信心有所增强(平均变化3.1,95%CI 3.0 - 3.3 NRS单位),并且在膝关节OA治疗计划中使用教育、强化运动和身体活动的可能性增加。学习的采用和实施情况(n = 149名受访者)在4个月时进行评估。超过一半的受访者在临床实践中利用所学知识组织与患者的面对面咨询(80/142,5