Holzhüter Fabian, Schuster Florian, Heres Stephan, Hamann Johannes
Klinik und Poliklinik für Psychiatrie und Psychotherapie, Klinikum rechts der Isar, Technische Universität München, Munich, Germany.
kbo-Isar-Amper-Klinikum München-Nord, Munich, Germany.
Front Psychiatry. 2021 Sep 13;12:721699. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2021.721699. eCollection 2021.
For psychiatric in-patients, ward rounds are a prominent occasion for decision making. As previous findings on shared decision-making (SDM) patterns mostly derive from out-patients and one-to-one-consultations, it was our aim to investigate SDM during psychiatric ward rounds. We conducted a cross-sectional study and included = 62 in-patients from seven different psychiatric wards. We collected data from the patient and the treating physician before and after ward rounds and recorded the interaction. We identified two groups of patients regarding their attitude toward ward rounds (no expectations vs. clear agenda). The latter showed higher active engagement, expected more decisions to be made and discussed more topics. Generally, observer rated SDM was low, with vast differences between the doctors' and the patients' perception. Doctors and patients perceive ward rounds differently and there is a discrepancy between subjective and objective involvement. A rather paternalistic doctor-patient-relationship is observed, while patients feel sufficiently involved and vastly satisfied. The potential of ward rounds maximizes if patients have an agenda. Consequently, motivating patients to prepare themselves toward ward rounds should be part of the weekly routine, as well as improving patient participation and information procedures during ward rounds.
对于精神科住院患者而言,查房是进行决策的重要时机。由于先前关于共同决策(SDM)模式的研究结果大多来自门诊患者和一对一咨询,我们旨在调查精神科查房期间的共同决策情况。我们进行了一项横断面研究,纳入了来自七个不同精神科病房的62名住院患者。我们在查房前后收集了患者和主治医生的数据,并记录了互动情况。我们根据患者对查房的态度(无期望与有明确议程)将患者分为两组。后者表现出更高的积极参与度,期望做出更多决策并讨论更多话题。总体而言,观察者评定的共同决策水平较低,医生和患者的认知存在巨大差异。医生和患者对查房的认知不同,主观参与度和客观参与度之间存在差异。观察到医患关系较为家长式,而患者感觉自己充分参与且非常满意。如果患者有议程,查房的潜力将得到最大发挥。因此,激励患者为查房做好准备应成为每周的常规工作,同时也要改善查房期间的患者参与度和信息程序。